Boost controller on S300 not consistent
Who is Mr Robot?
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 21,474
Likes: 10
From: ATL - Where the Pimps and Players dwell
The lower the duty cycle the lower the pressure, since the valve opens less.
Duty cycle is how much the valve cycles. High number = more cycles = less boost.
Duty cycle is how much the valve cycles. High number = more cycles = less boost.
If I put in 30% duty cycle lets just say it makes 10 lbs of boost. Then I'll put 25% duty cycle and now it makes 15 lbs of boost. Does the opposite if what you'd expect.
we cant seem to get my boost by gear to work boost cut every time, i sent the datalog,the s300 file etc to hondata, and all they said is check my waste gate, which clearly isn't the problem because its holds waste gate "10psi" , and it works fine with duty cycle, but the boost by gear just hits boost cut, also with mine the lower the duty the higher the boost. waste gate in 10psi 50% duty is 14psi 45% is 17psi im running a mac solenoid
we cant seem to get my boost by gear to work boost cut every time, i sent the datalog,the s300 file etc to hondata, and all they said is check my waste gate, which clearly isn't the problem because its holds waste gate "10psi" , and it works fine with duty cycle, but the boost by gear just hits boost cut, also with mine the lower the duty the higher the boost. waste gate in 10psi 50% duty is 14psi 45% is 17psi im running a mac solenoid
BTW I wouldn't be surprised of Hondata just glanced over your stuff and just threw out an option like wastegate. I don't think they have the resources to help every end user. When I first started playing with my S300 I emailed Hondata with some issues and they just old me to go through my reseller that I purchased it from and when I responded saying I had purchased the unit used and didn't have that option they just said sorry out of luck.
In the set up for boost control under normally closed or open. Select the opposite from what you have selected. As duty increase boost should also. If boost increases as duty decreases , the temp compensation tales won't work correctly.
Not true. My boost increases as duty cycle decreases and the temp compensation table works just fine. You just have to change the values in the table accordingly.
you flipped the the DC adjustment?
I would think the option for normally closed or normally open would allow you to set it up so boost always increases with DC
I would think the option for normally closed or normally open would allow you to set it up so boost always increases with DC
Have you tried another program.. something like like Neptune..?
The S300 isn't the end all be all of tuning software.
All experinces I've had with it, have been pretty much flawless.(neptune)
The S300 isn't the end all be all of tuning software.
All experinces I've had with it, have been pretty much flawless.(neptune)
No the option is for different kinds of solenoids. Some are normally open and some are normally closed. Read the help on that page in the S300. It explains it all.
We have everything setup correctly and try running boost buy gear and just hits boost cut even when put at 0 psi like OBRjosh stated. Its strange we have the setting correct for the MAC normally closed solenoid but we have to reduce duty cycle to get more boost and when increase duty cycle we get less boost on the fixed duty cycle setting. We havent tried the boost by gear with this method but i think next time at the track we will. We also tried the normally open setting and that doesnt change anything. Very strange to say the least but at least we figure it out.
Malcolm no matter which way you slice it the ecu cannot interpolate duty cycle and boost pressure. IDK why but it cant. The only thing it can do is decrease or increase due to intake temps when running boost by gear. Even when you run boost by gear target psi in the box above you have to set what duty equals what boost in the pressure vs duty cycle section.
best thing to do is make pulls and write down how much duty cycle equals what boost pressure. Then input all that data into that pressure vs duty cycle section. Then when you do boost by gear target psi it will interpolate off of those settings. When it gets warmer outside or colder outside and your over or underboosting make the temp corrections and you will have a rock solid boost control system
Malcolm no matter which way you slice it the ecu cannot interpolate duty cycle and boost pressure. IDK why but it cant. The only thing it can do is decrease or increase due to intake temps when running boost by gear. Even when you run boost by gear target psi in the box above you have to set what duty equals what boost in the pressure vs duty cycle section.
best thing to do is make pulls and write down how much duty cycle equals what boost pressure. Then input all that data into that pressure vs duty cycle section. Then when you do boost by gear target psi it will interpolate off of those settings. When it gets warmer outside or colder outside and your over or underboosting make the temp corrections and you will have a rock solid boost control system
Where is your Solenoid mounted? There is a chart to compensate for ambient tempatures since it should change in different ambient tempatures...however there is nothing to compensate for Transient Heat. If you have your solenoid is close to any high heat sources it can most definately effect its operations....Most of those mac solenoids are only desinged to around 176 or 80C max....Certain locations in the engine bay especially around the turbo can easily exceed those tempatures. Just something too keep in mind
Little off topic but the quick spool table has increased my response significantly.
Little off topic but the quick spool table has increased my response significantly.
cooler air will increase boost pressures. also if you haven't already done so, move your iat into your charge pipe and not the IM. heatsoak will **** up your iat corrections.
Posted from Honda-tech.com App for Android
Posted from Honda-tech.com App for Android
Malcolm no matter which way you slice it the ecu cannot interpolate duty cycle and boost pressure. IDK why but it cant. The only thing it can do is decrease or increase due to intake temps when running boost by gear. Even when you run boost by gear target psi in the box above you have to set what duty equals what boost in the pressure vs duty cycle section.
best thing to do is make pulls and write down how much duty cycle equals what boost pressure. Then input all that data into that pressure vs duty cycle section. Then when you do boost by gear target psi it will interpolate off of those settings. When it gets warmer outside or colder outside and your over or underboosting make the temp corrections and you will have a rock solid boost control system
best thing to do is make pulls and write down how much duty cycle equals what boost pressure. Then input all that data into that pressure vs duty cycle section. Then when you do boost by gear target psi it will interpolate off of those settings. When it gets warmer outside or colder outside and your over or underboosting make the temp corrections and you will have a rock solid boost control system
Yes my IAT is in the charge pipe.
who socketed the ecu? 99% of the time i have run into the issue of hitting boost cut when the boost control is turned on has resulted in a ecu socketing problem.
also somewhere along the lines i guess hondata was telling people to put resistors in-line with their boost solenoids...that has resulted in problems every time as well.
also somewhere along the lines i guess hondata was telling people to put resistors in-line with their boost solenoids...that has resulted in problems every time as well.
I asked Hondata awhile back about this feature and this is what they had to say:
Originally Posted by Hondata
PID control is difficult for boost control is some ways. To start with you need the wastegate and control solenoid plumbed correctly so that the natural boost curve is flat to begin with. Next you need a starting duty cycle to boost table and correction table. Then you need to tune a correction table and then go through the PID setup process, where you change P values to achieve a certain frequency, and then turn the I and D components. It turned into a lot of fiddling around, far more so that the straight duty lookup we currently use, and we felt many people would not achieve good boost control. Perhaps it will be an option in the future.
Maybe if enough people bug them they will add it.
Thanks for the info Spectacle. I'm sure they have their reasons if they say they do. I'm sure coding up the S300 software is no easy feat. Instead of all the correction tables they point out it seems like they could just make an add on to the existing setup. Sort of like open loop and closed loop on the fuel maps. Once you have your boost duty cycles dialed in or close to it like I have now it should have a "closed loop" option and now it'll reference to the MAP sensor to make slight adjustments as it goes off because of air temps etc.
It is although that diagram is very generic and doesn't label the ports on the solenoid. The ports are specific (at least mine was labeled as such). It specified which port vented to atmosphere and which went to wastegate and turbo.
I have this solenoid from phearable.net
I have this solenoid from phearable.net
It is although that diagram is very generic and doesn't label the ports on the solenoid. The ports are specific (at least mine was labeled as such). It specified which port vented to atmosphere and which went to wastegate and turbo.
I have this solenoid from phearable.net
I have this solenoid from phearable.net
My wastegate is a Tail. May I ask what is with the line of questioning? Is there a point you're trying to make or are you trying to troubleshoot something?
Trying to help out, and learn myself. Hopefully this post can be useful to others as well.
If the solenoid is connected below the diaphragm, I can understand why increased dc decrease boost.
If the solenoid is connected below the diaphragm, I can understand why increased dc decrease boost.
Who is Mr Robot?
iTrader: (2)
Joined: Jul 2004
Posts: 21,474
Likes: 10
From: ATL - Where the Pimps and Players dwell
Have you verified the solenoid is working properly?
And like above, I've never liked hondatas boost control methods... so much so it was worth me selling a chipped ecu and horse trading for an AEM ems... you tell it the solenoid, what boost level to run where, what rpm/load, gear, maybe adjust how aggressive the curve is (gain for people with a separate boost controller) and all you do is press the right pedal... the ecu looks at the map sensor value and does everything off of that.
Doesn't get much easier
And like above, I've never liked hondatas boost control methods... so much so it was worth me selling a chipped ecu and horse trading for an AEM ems... you tell it the solenoid, what boost level to run where, what rpm/load, gear, maybe adjust how aggressive the curve is (gain for people with a separate boost controller) and all you do is press the right pedal... the ecu looks at the map sensor value and does everything off of that.
Doesn't get much easier
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



