Super Charger on a civic?
#1
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Super Charger on a civic?
Why do so many people go against this? i mean turbo is good when you're trying to race people, but when you are daily driving , isn't a supercharger better? since it's not like you are gonna go past 4k every day .
i might plan to put a super charger on mine one day but i just want to know why a super charger over a turbo charger. why a turbo charger over a super charger. and i'm talking about a daily car that you won't race but when you wanna pass someone you feel the power when doing so.
i might plan to put a super charger on mine one day but i just want to know why a super charger over a turbo charger. why a turbo charger over a super charger. and i'm talking about a daily car that you won't race but when you wanna pass someone you feel the power when doing so.
#2
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: New York
Posts: 258
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
Two points might be pointed out. 1.The supercharger has a very annoying whine to it. 2. It works off belt and pulley... Which means the engine has to be rotating more faster adding extra pressure with could blow the engine.. Unlike turbo which uses the exhaust gases to push the turbine. Hence less unburnt fuel.
A supercharger set up will run you around the same area of a engine swap... Bigger engine..
A supercharger set up will run you around the same area of a engine swap... Bigger engine..
#3
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
There's covered a lot of times and one page isn't enough.
But the main difference in performance is Low vs Top Power.
Supercharger= instant power from take off but until certain RPM range when the HP/TQ curve went flat.
Turbo= Start to build boost later in the RPM range but once build is till Red line.
Other big concern is the cooling capacity:
Most superchargers are a heat source connected to your head intake side with out the ability of cooling it (root, screw types) most common for Honda. Raising your IAT's to sky, There's several companies that make Heat exchangers (root, screw) or intercoolers for the Centrifugal type but they are very pricey.
Turbo although they work with exhaust power a correct sized intercooler most of the time is enough to reliable control the temperatures.
This is a few differences.
For your driving style and not race in mind the Supercharger is a good way to go for D.D. but a good sized turbo kit do the trick perfect too.
Good luck!!!
But the main difference in performance is Low vs Top Power.
Supercharger= instant power from take off but until certain RPM range when the HP/TQ curve went flat.
Turbo= Start to build boost later in the RPM range but once build is till Red line.
Other big concern is the cooling capacity:
Most superchargers are a heat source connected to your head intake side with out the ability of cooling it (root, screw types) most common for Honda. Raising your IAT's to sky, There's several companies that make Heat exchangers (root, screw) or intercoolers for the Centrifugal type but they are very pricey.
Turbo although they work with exhaust power a correct sized intercooler most of the time is enough to reliable control the temperatures.
This is a few differences.
For your driving style and not race in mind the Supercharger is a good way to go for D.D. but a good sized turbo kit do the trick perfect too.
Good luck!!!
#4
Seagull Management
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Miramichi, NB, Canada
Posts: 15,150
Likes: 0
Received 24 Likes
on
22 Posts
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
The biggest problem with a supercharger on a 4 cylinder is the amount of power required to turn the supercharger in the first place. There's not a whole lot of net gain, especially not for the money. You're better off with a small, quick spooling turbo.
#5
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Dub Caesar, PA
Posts: 1,644
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
My old car. Running 7.5psi. It was a lot of fun as a DD, but no where near "fast". As for the whine being annoying, that is purely an opinion. I loved it.
#7
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
supercharging is useful when you have displacement..
ergo why when you are boosting a honda, 9 times out of 10 it isnt a supercharger.
ergo why when you are boosting a honda, 9 times out of 10 it isnt a supercharger.
Trending Topics
#8
I never narc'd on nobody!
iTrader: (1)
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
Like 94eg8 said, the biggest problem with a supercharger is the parasitic loss. It takes power to make power, unlike a turbo that just makes power. Unless you use a centrifugal supercharger, aftercoolers are more complicated (and more expensive) to install than intercoolers, and the generated heat is another loss in power. The supercharger whine is completely subjective - some people like it, some people hate it, some people don't even notice it.
Since you specifically mentioned daily driving a FI car, there's one other thing that no one else has mentioned yet - exhaust noise. Superchargers like big, unrestricted, wide open exhausts. That kind of exhaust is loud. A turbo acts as a baffle in your exhaust, making it naturally quieter. If you live somewhere with strict noise codes for cars, turbo is definitely the way to go - staying legal with a supercharger would just be shooting yourself in the foot.
Since you specifically mentioned daily driving a FI car, there's one other thing that no one else has mentioned yet - exhaust noise. Superchargers like big, unrestricted, wide open exhausts. That kind of exhaust is loud. A turbo acts as a baffle in your exhaust, making it naturally quieter. If you live somewhere with strict noise codes for cars, turbo is definitely the way to go - staying legal with a supercharger would just be shooting yourself in the foot.
#9
B*a*n*n*e*d
iTrader: (15)
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: montebello, ca, us
Posts: 6,632
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
10 Posts
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
Two points might be pointed out. 1.The supercharger has a very annoying whine to it. 2. It works off belt and pulley... Which means the engine has to be rotating more faster adding extra pressure with could blow the engine.. Unlike turbo which uses the exhaust gases to push the turbine. Hence less unburnt fuel.
A supercharger set up will run you around the same area of a engine swap... Bigger engine..
A supercharger set up will run you around the same area of a engine swap... Bigger engine..
This post is just full of stupid.
There's covered a lot of times and one page isn't enough.
But the main difference in performance is Low vs Top Power.
Supercharger= instant power from take off but until certain RPM range when the HP/TQ curve went flat.
Turbo= Start to build boost later in the RPM range but once build is till Red line.
Other big concern is the cooling capacity:
Most superchargers are a heat source connected to your head intake side with out the ability of cooling it (root, screw types) most common for Honda. Raising your IAT's to sky, There's several companies that make Heat exchangers (root, screw) or intercoolers for the Centrifugal type but they are very pricey.
Turbo although they work with exhaust power a correct sized intercooler most of the time is enough to reliable control the temperatures.
This is a few differences.
For your driving style and not race in mind the Supercharger is a good way to go for D.D. but a good sized turbo kit do the trick perfect too.
Good luck!!!
But the main difference in performance is Low vs Top Power.
Supercharger= instant power from take off but until certain RPM range when the HP/TQ curve went flat.
Turbo= Start to build boost later in the RPM range but once build is till Red line.
Other big concern is the cooling capacity:
Most superchargers are a heat source connected to your head intake side with out the ability of cooling it (root, screw types) most common for Honda. Raising your IAT's to sky, There's several companies that make Heat exchangers (root, screw) or intercoolers for the Centrifugal type but they are very pricey.
Turbo although they work with exhaust power a correct sized intercooler most of the time is enough to reliable control the temperatures.
This is a few differences.
For your driving style and not race in mind the Supercharger is a good way to go for D.D. but a good sized turbo kit do the trick perfect too.
Good luck!!!
Ever heard of a gt28rs?
To the op.
If you want instant power for daily driving build a setup with a small turbo. Figure out a horsepower goal and go from there. Look up user tonythetiger he knows all about instant boost lol
#11
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
Why do so many people go against this? i mean turbo is good when you're trying to race people, but when you are daily driving , isn't a supercharger better? since it's not like you are gonna go past 4k every day .
i might plan to put a super charger on mine one day but i just want to know why a super charger over a turbo charger. why a turbo charger over a super charger. and i'm talking about a daily car that you won't race but when you wanna pass someone you feel the power when doing so.
i might plan to put a super charger on mine one day but i just want to know why a super charger over a turbo charger. why a turbo charger over a super charger. and i'm talking about a daily car that you won't race but when you wanna pass someone you feel the power when doing so.
4k....go over that every day. Hell I'm pretty sure I'll hit 6800 at least once per trip I take with it. Boost, it's fun. I love the sounds of the turbo, the BOV, the wastegate. It's so much of a joy I don't even bother with the stereo, ever. I don't race it, I just enjoy it...a lot. I don't care if I'm side by side with an R32 or all on my own, I just like enjoying my car.
You will go over 4k, often once you have a toy that adds boost. Charger or Turbo.
That said, I struggle with traction issues in 1st with just 5psi, I don't even let the turbo get to 7, it's pointless.
Supercharger/Turbo, it's really up to you and what you want.
#12
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
Since you specifically mentioned daily driving a FI car, there's one other thing that no one else has mentioned yet - exhaust noise. Superchargers like big, unrestricted, wide open exhausts. That kind of exhaust is loud. A turbo acts as a baffle in your exhaust, making it naturally quieter. If you live somewhere with strict noise codes for cars, turbo is definitely the way to go - staying legal with a supercharger would just be shooting yourself in the foot.
They both like big open exhausts. The turbo may be a baffle but it's not that big of an effect.
Engines are air pumps, the easier it can pump the air the more power it's going to make.
#13
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Oct 2011
Location: New York
Posts: 258
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
What ever my post said it's the similar as 94EG8 is trying to explain.... The engine has to spin so much harder to make power which in case is a 4 banger that with excess pressure and stock internal your engine will immediately snap..
The OP asked about a supercharger as opposed to turbo... He never asked on the types of turbo.
#14
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (3)
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
I believe you can get better fuel economy with a turbo than you can with a supercharger based on spooling characteristics. I believe that is why there is a shift in the current auto industry to turbocharging smaller motors instead of large discplacement motors.
#15
I never narc'd on nobody!
iTrader: (1)
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
You can't just make blanket statements and compare all superchargers to all turbochargers. It doesn't work that way.
#16
B*a*n*n*e*d
iTrader: (15)
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: montebello, ca, us
Posts: 6,632
Likes: 0
Received 15 Likes
on
10 Posts
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
Look at his screen name lulz . Someone needs to edit out posts like his so false info doesn't keep spreading.
Last edited by turbohatch96y7; 02-17-2014 at 12:32 PM.
#17
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
im speaking hypothetically, ive never heard one say that specifically..
#18
Seagull Management
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Miramichi, NB, Canada
Posts: 15,150
Likes: 0
Received 24 Likes
on
22 Posts
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
It has more to do with making the EPA estimates look good for CAFE standards than anything else. An F-150 with a V6 Eco-Boost gets great mileage, until you try to haul or tow something with it.
#19
Who is Mr Robot?
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Jul 2004
Location: ATL - Where the Pimps and Players dwell
Posts: 21,474
Likes: 0
Received 10 Likes
on
10 Posts
Re: Super Charger on a civic?
the internet these days... fml. reminds me of that state farm commercial about everything on the internet being true trololol
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
DJThomas1189
Honda Civic (2001 - 2005)
12
05-07-2007 10:27 PM