rigid collar
#30
Re: rigid collar
Go for it ,there is nothing wrong with making money. When it comes to car lovers they will buy anything. If you don't do it someone else will, most likely the same people who told you it's a ridiculous idea.
#32
Honda-Tech Member
Re: rigid collar
#33
Re: rigid collar
Its amazing how people will look at something in arrogance and dismiss it as snake oil ... the racing community has become too ****ing conservative and left its innovation long behind.
The real reason people attack this idea is because of the price and the insignificance in structure or size. What can a little puny washer do? Eh? Apparently, people have felt an amazing difference, night and day even, yet we have the "experts" and "pro's" and "racers" coming on here and flaming a product just because of the price and because their "theoretical" analysis says so because it is "common sense" ... as if you guys manufactured a car or engineered one for that matter.
I will suggest this to anyone talking **** ...
DON'T ****ING BUY IT. PERIOD.
Stop telling people how to spend their money, if they feel a difference after install, good for them ... now get lost. "Trial and error" ... the racing community has always been about that. It has never been, "oh ... racer X did it this way, so it must be." or "Oh, I race every weekend, I know what I'm talking about." People seem to think that the greatest ideas are the most complex, arrogant fools only complicate their own lives.
The real reason people attack this idea is because of the price and the insignificance in structure or size. What can a little puny washer do? Eh? Apparently, people have felt an amazing difference, night and day even, yet we have the "experts" and "pro's" and "racers" coming on here and flaming a product just because of the price and because their "theoretical" analysis says so because it is "common sense" ... as if you guys manufactured a car or engineered one for that matter.
I will suggest this to anyone talking **** ...
DON'T ****ING BUY IT. PERIOD.
Stop telling people how to spend their money, if they feel a difference after install, good for them ... now get lost. "Trial and error" ... the racing community has always been about that. It has never been, "oh ... racer X did it this way, so it must be." or "Oh, I race every weekend, I know what I'm talking about." People seem to think that the greatest ideas are the most complex, arrogant fools only complicate their own lives.
#34
Re: rigid collar
edit: Seems to me the OP's post states the problem to be that bolts loosen over time so why on earth would the best solution be something so involved and complicated?
#36
Honda-Tech Member
Re: rigid collar
The main purpose is to align the subframe perfectly. If your caster is off side to side it will be from a bent part, and you can narrow it down easier when one thing is centered. The bolt holes do have slop, unless you have access to an alignment rack you won't get them centered. For $100 I see it as a valuable modification. Whether it will feel like a solid welded subframe or not, I have no idea and I doubt it will. If I ever get around to installing it, I will report back and let everyone know.
#37
#38
Honda-Tech Member
Re: rigid collar
Amazing what a bottle of white-out and a torque wrench can do.
If you think these work, before buying, do this:
1. lift car up in air
2. Retorque subframe bolts
3. Mark bolt alignment with white-out
4. Track/race car
5. Lift car up and review marks.
I did this exact thing, after driving over kerbing and other subframe jolting driving. No movement. all marks on bolts for torque and alignment were right where I marked them.
If you think these work, before buying, do this:
1. lift car up in air
2. Retorque subframe bolts
3. Mark bolt alignment with white-out
4. Track/race car
5. Lift car up and review marks.
I did this exact thing, after driving over kerbing and other subframe jolting driving. No movement. all marks on bolts for torque and alignment were right where I marked them.
#39
Honda-Tech Member
Re: rigid collar
Agreed however the join can still lose clamping load without the bolt head turning from bolt or mating component yield. But a quick retorque will make up for that.
#40
Honda-Tech Member
Re: rigid collar
The main purpose is to align the subframe perfectly. If your caster is off side to side it will be from a bent part, and you can narrow it down easier when one thing is centered. The bolt holes do have slop, unless you have access to an alignment rack you won't get them centered.
Your head would probably explode if you saw the manufacturing tolerance on a subframe.
#41
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: MA
Posts: 3,569
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: rigid collar
Its amazing how people will look at something in arrogance and dismiss it as snake oil ... the racing community has become too ****ing conservative and left its innovation long behind.
The real reason people attack this idea is because of the price and the insignificance in structure or size. What can a little puny washer do? Eh? Apparently, people have felt an amazing difference, night and day even, yet we have the "experts" and "pro's" and "racers" coming on here and flaming a product just because of the price and because their "theoretical" analysis says so because it is "common sense" ... as if you guys manufactured a car or engineered one for that matter.
I will suggest this to anyone talking **** ...
DON'T ****ING BUY IT. PERIOD.
Stop telling people how to spend their money, if they feel a difference after install, good for them ... now get lost. "Trial and error" ... the racing community has always been about that. It has never been, "oh ... racer X did it this way, so it must be." or "Oh, I race every weekend, I know what I'm talking about." People seem to think that the greatest ideas are the most complex, arrogant fools only complicate their own lives.
The real reason people attack this idea is because of the price and the insignificance in structure or size. What can a little puny washer do? Eh? Apparently, people have felt an amazing difference, night and day even, yet we have the "experts" and "pro's" and "racers" coming on here and flaming a product just because of the price and because their "theoretical" analysis says so because it is "common sense" ... as if you guys manufactured a car or engineered one for that matter.
I will suggest this to anyone talking **** ...
DON'T ****ING BUY IT. PERIOD.
Stop telling people how to spend their money, if they feel a difference after install, good for them ... now get lost. "Trial and error" ... the racing community has always been about that. It has never been, "oh ... racer X did it this way, so it must be." or "Oh, I race every weekend, I know what I'm talking about." People seem to think that the greatest ideas are the most complex, arrogant fools only complicate their own lives.
#43
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2006
Location: Racine, WI, United States
Posts: 1,288
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: rigid collar
I don't know what effects they truly have on a car, mainly becuase i do have more important modifications to fulfill to my car. This is a modification for racing teams with unlimited budgets. Where everything is already done that can be done, so they go and find one more thing that could be perfected.
It is my understanding that most people that buy this modification are just Spoon fan boys that want just a little more Spoon bling on their car so they can talk about while they hard park. You all know the type, "Dude i have a Spoon muffler, oil cap, radiator, and so on.". Problem is that Spoon jacks the rates of all their goods because they know suckers out there will buy it solely because it's a Spoon product. Much like going to buy a Mugen oil pan, which is nothing more than an OEM Honda oil pan with about $3.00 worth of extra steel or aluminum welded in for baffles. The same metal you can buy and weld yourself, but Mugen will charge a bazillion dollars for it. Half the time companies like Spoon and Mugen outsource to larger shops to have the product made, then they laser-etch their logo on the part and magically it goes jumps 400% in value. Those shops are too small to produce so many parts. So you're buying the name and not the part.
I would look at this as a very last option to do on a car. And if Blox happens to mimic the product so be it, that's life in the corporate realm. Anyone that knocks someone for being budget minded and purchasing a quality product at a cheaper rate is a moron. Racing is about being frugal with your money so that you can spend it on more track time and consumables, such as tires and brake rotors/pads.
The racing world doesn't have time for your superiority complex! Get over yourself!
It is my understanding that most people that buy this modification are just Spoon fan boys that want just a little more Spoon bling on their car so they can talk about while they hard park. You all know the type, "Dude i have a Spoon muffler, oil cap, radiator, and so on.". Problem is that Spoon jacks the rates of all their goods because they know suckers out there will buy it solely because it's a Spoon product. Much like going to buy a Mugen oil pan, which is nothing more than an OEM Honda oil pan with about $3.00 worth of extra steel or aluminum welded in for baffles. The same metal you can buy and weld yourself, but Mugen will charge a bazillion dollars for it. Half the time companies like Spoon and Mugen outsource to larger shops to have the product made, then they laser-etch their logo on the part and magically it goes jumps 400% in value. Those shops are too small to produce so many parts. So you're buying the name and not the part.
The racing world doesn't have time for your superiority complex! Get over yourself!
#46
ProFunction/GT Motoring
Join Date: May 2001
Location: IL
Posts: 4,930
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#48
Honda-Tech Member
Re: rigid collar
The only thing I have noticed with having the subframe off is you can move the subframe side to side and front to rear about 3mm in any direction meaning you could be 6mm total off side to side if you pushed one side forward and the other back. Am I saying these are worth it? I dont know... Do I own them, no but maybe I might for the ease of centering parts and nothing more.
#49
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (1)
Re: rigid collar
Surprised this topic is still going really.
That play in the subframe is a useful thing when aligning the car. At the dealer (many moons ago) we used to loosen those bolts and shift the subframe around to fix strange pulls and misaligned caster. Pretty sure the was a TSB for it on the ~98 Accords/Odysseys. Either that or we got it from a field engineer. Either way, it was a handy technique that I used a lot on several chassis to really get my alignments dialed in. I've always been a bit OCD about my alignments.
The main purpose is to align the subframe perfectly. If your caster is off side to side it will be from a bent part, and you can narrow it down easier when one thing is centered. The bolt holes do have slop, unless you have access to an alignment rack you won't get them centered. For $100 I see it as a valuable modification. Whether it will feel like a solid welded subframe or not, I have no idea and I doubt it will. If I ever get around to installing it, I will report back and let everyone know.
The only thing I have noticed with having the subframe off is you can move the subframe side to side and front to rear about 3mm in any direction meaning you could be 6mm total off side to side if you pushed one side forward and the other back. Am I saying these are worth it? I dont know... Do I own them, no but maybe I might for the ease of centering parts and nothing more.
#50
Honda-Tech Member
Re: rigid collar
I am personally saving up for the Fork press fit piston kit. The days of dealing with piston ring "slop" are over. You just interference fit the Fork Signature Series pistons in your block and you will never have to worry about annoying issues those guys with a rotating assembly encounter.
Fork - "Fighting slop in a flat brimmed hat since 2012."
Fork - "Fighting slop in a flat brimmed hat since 2012."