The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
#27
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Long Island, N.y, usa
Posts: 2,353
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
Actually, it really wasn't that expensive compared to what you're seeing because we did an entire package. it was about $60 to recon the rods. $50 to polish crank, $40 for the ARP rod bolts (remember, B20/D16 bolts are less expensive than the VTEC ones). Balancing the entire assembly was $200, Pistons were $450. No charge for the resurfacing of items. Even a set of decent forged rods would have been $300 a set
We didn't want to use a cast piston because none of those offered gave us the compression we wanted with the build we were making. It was either too low, or too high. Plus, there was a warranty associated from Wiseco from our machine shop, so it was nice added insurance.
This wasn't about what was necessarily cheaper. It was about what was correct for the application. I'm not saying we're swimming in dough, its just if you're going do it, just don't eff around.
We didn't want to use a cast piston because none of those offered gave us the compression we wanted with the build we were making. It was either too low, or too high. Plus, there was a warranty associated from Wiseco from our machine shop, so it was nice added insurance.
This wasn't about what was necessarily cheaper. It was about what was correct for the application. I'm not saying we're swimming in dough, its just if you're going do it, just don't eff around.
#28
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
(Have you seen what the V8 guys pay in comparison to us? Its ridiculous.. they are SOOOO Cheap. We pay for 4 pistons what they get for 8)
You young guys today have it GREAT!!! Ebay companies, RS Machine, CP, JE, SRP, with a plethora of choices from a ton of other acrynoms. Not to mention the competative pricing on Honda parts and specialty machine shops that do only Hondas and the like (Laskey Racing, RLZ, DonF, Alainz,etc). While we grew up on the Skunkworks,com, Inlinefour, JDMSH!T.com, Endyn, and Japanese Honda Parts.com (Now JHPUSA) and had to beg for machine shops to invest in parts that were more inline with bikes than actual cars (at least to them). Most of them told us to take a walk, so I'm happy as hell now.
But, us old dudes (Old in the realm of the Honda aftermarket) at the same time are stubborn, So, we get OEM, or Full aftermarket forged. none of that "in between" stuff. (Trust me, when planning this build, I considered RS Machines.. then the little hairs on the back of my neck said.... "nah, get what you KNOW works."
In IL and MI we have a TON of machine shops that work on stuff all the time, so machining really is a fun privilege that we don't get very often with those guys. So the fact that they were willing to do great work on even Honduhss is a rare opportunity.
We're just of a different philosophy of thinking is all. ;-) (We've had this discussion before)
#29
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Jan 2003
Location: Long Island, N.y, usa
Posts: 2,353
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
LOL yea im more than sure we've had a similar conversation. The philosophy is different, but the pursuit of the final outcome is the same and that is to create a solid build. I agree that there is a lot more companies and machine shops that offer great parts that you OG's didn't have before. None the less, its still humbling to hear you guys stories and see that you guys stick with the methods that you guys know best.
#30
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
LOL yea im more than sure we've had a similar conversation. The philosophy is different, but the pursuit of the final outcome is the same and that is to create a solid build. I agree that there is a lot more companies and machine shops that offer great parts that you OG's didn't have before. None the less, its still humbling to hear you guys stories and see that you guys stick with the methods that you guys know best.
#32
Purpose Built
Join Date: Jan 2011
Location: Natural Aspiratopia
Posts: 3,090
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
Biggest thing the newer (my) generation lacks is the ability to admit fault and learn from our mistakes. We are living in a closed minded society and unfortunatly everything, even the honda building scene lol, is effected by it
#33
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
Most expect a solid build. Unfortunatly the majority expect it from cornercut/hacked builds and then looks for a scape goat to blame the fail on
Biggest thing the newer (my) generation lacks is the ability to admit fault and learn from our mistakes. We are living in a closed minded society and unfortunatly everything, even the honda building scene lol, is effected by it
Biggest thing the newer (my) generation lacks is the ability to admit fault and learn from our mistakes. We are living in a closed minded society and unfortunatly everything, even the honda building scene lol, is effected by it
#34
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
5.14.11 *Update*
Block was Machine Grey painted and Autowerks team is now working on engine assembly.
Thanks to Tonio and his instructional video to show everyone, The head is first being worked on with a slight mill (.004") and then begin the arduous process of degreeing the camshafts properly.
We have to, of course, lock the VTEC rocker so the correct cam lobe can be degreed in.
For those that need to know the Skunk2 Pro 1 settings and protocols for the valvetrain, see below.
http://www.skunk2.com/installation/305-05-5140.pdf
According to Brian, When degreeing the cams Valvelash needs to be at OEM specifications.
Pro Series Springs:
60lbs closed seat pressure
Install Height - 1 inch @ 320
210 lbs pressure Open @ .5 inch lift
Coil bind - Height 720 @ 600 Lift
Block was Machine Grey painted and Autowerks team is now working on engine assembly.
Thanks to Tonio and his instructional video to show everyone, The head is first being worked on with a slight mill (.004") and then begin the arduous process of degreeing the camshafts properly.
We have to, of course, lock the VTEC rocker so the correct cam lobe can be degreed in.
For those that need to know the Skunk2 Pro 1 settings and protocols for the valvetrain, see below.
http://www.skunk2.com/installation/305-05-5140.pdf
According to Brian, When degreeing the cams Valvelash needs to be at OEM specifications.
Pro Series Springs:
60lbs closed seat pressure
Install Height - 1 inch @ 320
210 lbs pressure Open @ .5 inch lift
Coil bind - Height 720 @ 600 Lift
Last edited by TheShodan; 11-10-2014 at 03:18 PM.
#36
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
The process is in the video narrative. (Just listen carefully). The purpose is to ensure that the VTEC cam lobe is engaged while the degree wheels are being used to properly "dial in" the camshafts properly. What one has to do for those that plan to use VTEC is to dial in as though VTEC were already engaged. The video shows him using air pressure to engage the VTEC solenoid (normally activiated) by oil pressure, so that the third cam locks in and can't be moved. Only then will he use dialing guages to make sure the camshafts are properly degreed.
#37
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Aug 2010
Location: Maryland
Posts: 2,686
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
The process is in the video narrative. (Just listen carefully). The purpose is to ensure that the VTEC cam lobe is engaged while the degree wheels are being used to properly "dial in" the camshafts properly. What one has to do for those that plan to use VTEC is to dial in as though VTEC were already engaged. The video shows him using air pressure to engage the VTEC solenoid (normally activiated) by oil pressure, so that the third cam locks in and can't be moved. Only then will he use dialing guages to make sure the camshafts are properly degreed.
#40
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
*UPDATE*
Engine has now been assembled. Excuse a couple of smudges, gloves weren't changed, but everything will be cleaned up accordingly.
Looks like the thing left to do is to address the head a bit more. As we were disassembling the head and taking out the valves, we noticed how OLD this head was. Remember, not only did Ron have this B16A swap into the Ferio since 2000, but it was this very B16A that was in japan for over 70K before he even bought it. So we figure this head has seen an easy 230K of abuse over 10 years. The valves had so much carbon and corrosion that a lot of it was fused to the actual valve stem. It was to a point that replacements were in serious order.
Thanks to our machine shop he was able to get us a great deal on some Ferrea valves. (This was done while we had the head washed, cleaned and resurfaced for a better seal) They aren't Nitrite treated, they'll do. Normally, we would go oversized and do a 3 angle valve job, but its just not in the budget. We'll get the new valves and "lap" them so that they seal properly. We had thought ahead and replaced the valve stem seals.
Engine has now been assembled. Excuse a couple of smudges, gloves weren't changed, but everything will be cleaned up accordingly.
Looks like the thing left to do is to address the head a bit more. As we were disassembling the head and taking out the valves, we noticed how OLD this head was. Remember, not only did Ron have this B16A swap into the Ferio since 2000, but it was this very B16A that was in japan for over 70K before he even bought it. So we figure this head has seen an easy 230K of abuse over 10 years. The valves had so much carbon and corrosion that a lot of it was fused to the actual valve stem. It was to a point that replacements were in serious order.
Thanks to our machine shop he was able to get us a great deal on some Ferrea valves. (This was done while we had the head washed, cleaned and resurfaced for a better seal) They aren't Nitrite treated, they'll do. Normally, we would go oversized and do a 3 angle valve job, but its just not in the budget. We'll get the new valves and "lap" them so that they seal properly. We had thought ahead and replaced the valve stem seals.
#41
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: oregon
Posts: 953
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
*UPDATE*
Engine has now been assembled. Excuse a couple of smudges, gloves weren't changed, but everything will be cleaned up accordingly.
Looks like the thing left to do is to address the head a bit more. As we were disassembling the head and taking out the valves, we noticed how OLD this head was. Remember, not only did Ron have this B16A swap into the Ferio since 2000, but it was this very B16A that was in japan for over 70K before he even bought it. So we figure this head has seen an easy 230K of abuse over 10 years. The valves had so much carbon and corrosion that a lot of it was fused to the actual valve stem. It was to a point that replacements were in serious order.
Thanks to our machine shop he was able to get us a great deal on some Ferrea valves. (This was done while we had the head washed, cleaned and resurfaced for a better seal) They aren't Nitrite treated, they'll do. Normally, we would go oversized and do a 3 angle valve job, but its just not in the budget. We'll get the new valves and "lap" them so that they seal properly. We had thought ahead and replaced the valve stem seals.
Engine has now been assembled. Excuse a couple of smudges, gloves weren't changed, but everything will be cleaned up accordingly.
Looks like the thing left to do is to address the head a bit more. As we were disassembling the head and taking out the valves, we noticed how OLD this head was. Remember, not only did Ron have this B16A swap into the Ferio since 2000, but it was this very B16A that was in japan for over 70K before he even bought it. So we figure this head has seen an easy 230K of abuse over 10 years. The valves had so much carbon and corrosion that a lot of it was fused to the actual valve stem. It was to a point that replacements were in serious order.
Thanks to our machine shop he was able to get us a great deal on some Ferrea valves. (This was done while we had the head washed, cleaned and resurfaced for a better seal) They aren't Nitrite treated, they'll do. Normally, we would go oversized and do a 3 angle valve job, but its just not in the budget. We'll get the new valves and "lap" them so that they seal properly. We had thought ahead and replaced the valve stem seals.
#42
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
I haven't seen any cons to doing this unless it was on a fresh valve job. It does need lapping compound, and we have to make sure that none gets on the valve stem itself. this is used to seat and ensure it closes properly.
Check here:
https://honda-tech.com/forums/all-motor-naturally-aspirated-44/easier-way-lap-valves-2866190/page2/#post44142594
I believe in the full valve job, but I'll let others give their input
#44
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
7.8.2011 Update
Welp, after long discussion, we decided to listen to the machine shop's recommendation and have the new valves angled to fit. A small "valvejob" as the term would be. I just didn't like the possibility that the valve wouldn't seat exactly after lapping, as the cylinder head easily has over 200K on it using the original OEM valves. Over time, with THAT much mileage, I just wasn't convinced that the lapping job would suffice, and wasn't willing to remove the head again to fix something that we knew could be solved now. Luckily, since we got a great discount on the valves from the machine shop, they only charged us minimally to do the valve job. That convinced all of us to go ahead with the proper way to do it. ( I try as much as possible to practice what I preach)
Welp, after long discussion, we decided to listen to the machine shop's recommendation and have the new valves angled to fit. A small "valvejob" as the term would be. I just didn't like the possibility that the valve wouldn't seat exactly after lapping, as the cylinder head easily has over 200K on it using the original OEM valves. Over time, with THAT much mileage, I just wasn't convinced that the lapping job would suffice, and wasn't willing to remove the head again to fix something that we knew could be solved now. Luckily, since we got a great discount on the valves from the machine shop, they only charged us minimally to do the valve job. That convinced all of us to go ahead with the proper way to do it. ( I try as much as possible to practice what I preach)
#46
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
This build is absolutely beautiful. I wanted to know since you choose a B18B Block -211.84mm, And LS Rods with Forged Pistons, would you ever want to install an oil squirter kit? If you had chosen OEM cast pistons that have the correct compression for your application, would you have chosen to install an oil squirter kit? The video you showed about semi-floating wrist pins being headed up and installed onto the con rods, does that install method not apply to fully floating wrist pins if you had chosen forged rods?
#48
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
Search google under "Project EM1 The Shodan goes N/A", you'll see the reasoning behind it.
Correct. The full floating pin in a forged rod should install right in, if not, the rod bushing may need to be slightly bored in order for it to fit properly. This has happened on ocassion with a forged rod.
Last edited by TheShodan; 07-09-2011 at 06:13 AM.
#49
Honda-Tech Member
#50
Re: The Shodan & Project "SHE"?
I hope things are well, and that things are going well for you. Give me a call at the lab sometime. Pete gives his regards.