My wife has a 98 Accord 4-cyl 5-spd. It had the ignition switch recall a few years ago.

Lately, she said she'd turn the key and the first few times nothing would happen, and then it'd start right up. It usually only happens when the car is cold. The key also feels a little notchy sometimes, which made me think it was the ignition switch. However, last time the switch went out it'd start fine but stall while driving. No problems with that this time- once it's running, it's fine.

This morning, it was doing it again so I went out to see for myself. The solenoid was clicking when I'd turn the key, but the starter wouldn't activate. Then, after 6 or 7 twists it starts up nice and strong as though nothing was ever wrong.

The solenoid with no start is a classic failed starter, but the eventual strong, normal start and notchy key feel makes me think it may be the ignition switch.

Is this ever a symptom of a failed ignition switch (seems like the solenoid shouldn't even click if that were the problem)?

 

Likely a starter problem.

 

Well once the starter turns it's gonna be strong unless the engine lacks spark. I'd swap the starter and test. Only way is process of Elimination. You can probably test the starter for continuity

 

The solenoid is the actual culprit here, but since Honda doesn't see fit to make it separately serviceable; you'll be required to replace the whole starter.
The solenoid is the heavy duty relay in this circuit, and if you can hear it engaging (with no related response from the starter); it's toast.

P

 

replace starter.

 

might be worn batt cables or dirty causing a bad connection.

 

Sounds like a relay problem. Check the main relay and the starter relay..but its definitely an electrical issue.