Header shootout from public data - JDM/Mugen ECU vs Comptech FHE & ECU vs HyTech & VAFC
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 4,049
Likes: 2
From: Snowwhitepillowformybigfathead
I'm writing this because I heard that Vago put out a nice number at Area 51 with his HyTech equipped ITR, and it made me want to look at what had been published. The peak number we all know tells a tiny piece of the story - I was keen on what kind of performance the HyTech equipped car delivered thruout the useful powerband. Here is my tabular summary of Andy's data (JDM Header, Mugen ECU, FPR), Comptech's data from their website, and the old data from Austin's run last year (the same one John had with him at the Expo).
And, yes, I know I'm comparing different dyno's on different days...blah, blah, blah......It's all there is in the public record. Note: Comptech didn't publish torque.
(Added: Area 51 is a Clayton (supposed to read lower than a DynoJet))
(Added: Johns data from Vago's run)
--------------Andy----------------------Comptech-----------------HyTech-Austin-------------HyTech-Vago
RPM---------TQ/HP---------------------TQ/HP------------------------TQ/HP--------------------TQ/HP
5000--------118/113------------------xxx/110----------------------114/109------------------122/117
5500--------122/127------------------xxx/122----------------------121/127------------------120/126
6000--------132/152------------------xxx/146----------------------129/148------------------137/157
6500--------130/161------------------xxx/163----------------------126/156------------------129/158
7000--------128/171------------------xxx/173----------------------125/166------------------129/170
7500--------128/183------------------xxx/181----------------------126/178------------------130/185
8000--------124/188------------------xxx/183----------------------124/187------------------127/189
Note: Austin's car had a full streetable HyTech exhaust (which I didn't like the sound of as much as a Mugen Twin Loop and whatever RMR was running at Expo). Andy has some kind of straight thru muffler dumping under the car.
Scott, who doesn't need a flame suit because flame is transient.....
[Modified by RR98ITR, 5:21 PM 1/24/2002]
And, yes, I know I'm comparing different dyno's on different days...blah, blah, blah......It's all there is in the public record. Note: Comptech didn't publish torque.
(Added: Area 51 is a Clayton (supposed to read lower than a DynoJet))
(Added: Johns data from Vago's run)
--------------Andy----------------------Comptech-----------------HyTech-Austin-------------HyTech-Vago
RPM---------TQ/HP---------------------TQ/HP------------------------TQ/HP--------------------TQ/HP
5000--------118/113------------------xxx/110----------------------114/109------------------122/117
5500--------122/127------------------xxx/122----------------------121/127------------------120/126
6000--------132/152------------------xxx/146----------------------129/148------------------137/157
6500--------130/161------------------xxx/163----------------------126/156------------------129/158
7000--------128/171------------------xxx/173----------------------125/166------------------129/170
7500--------128/183------------------xxx/181----------------------126/178------------------130/185
8000--------124/188------------------xxx/183----------------------124/187------------------127/189
Note: Austin's car had a full streetable HyTech exhaust (which I didn't like the sound of as much as a Mugen Twin Loop and whatever RMR was running at Expo). Andy has some kind of straight thru muffler dumping under the car.
Scott, who doesn't need a flame suit because flame is transient.....
[Modified by RR98ITR, 5:21 PM 1/24/2002]
Scott, who doesn't need a flame suit because flame is transient.....

Trying to draw any conclusions from that mess is kind of silly, don't you think?
Three diff cars...diff dynos...geez who cares... buy a header you like and can afford, it'll work fine. I thoguht we all learned that in the big header test.
Well... unless you're spending $10k on your motor, then yeah, you need a big ol thing that costs $1000.
Three diff cars...diff dynos...geez who cares... buy a header you like and can afford, it'll work fine. I thoguht we all learned that in the big header test.

Well... unless you're spending $10k on your motor, then yeah, you need a big ol thing that costs $1000.
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: Feb 2000
Posts: 4,049
Likes: 2
From: Snowwhitepillowformybigfathead
Trying to draw any conclusions from that mess is kind of silly, don't you think?
Three diff cars...diff dynos...geez who cares... buy a header you like and can afford, it'll work fine. I thoguht we all learned that in the big header test.
Well... unless you're spending $10k on your motor, then yeah, you need a big ol thing that costs $1000.
Three diff cars...diff dynos...geez who cares... buy a header you like and can afford, it'll work fine. I thoguht we all learned that in the big header test.

Well... unless you're spending $10k on your motor, then yeah, you need a big ol thing that costs $1000.
Scott, who hopes nobody makes too big a deal about this stuff.....I'm certainly not trying to...
All cars are running stock TBs, intakes and cams - how can they possibly differ that much in terms of air flow (cfm)? Airflow and fuel determine power right?
Trending Topics
Trying to draw any conclusions from that mess is kind of silly, don't you think?
I've got something similar but all run on the same dyno.
1- ITR motor w/ CTR pistons, JDM 4-1 and Skunk2 cams
2- ITR motor w/ ITR pistons, DC JDM and stock cams
3- ITR motor w/ ITR pistons, DC JDM and ported head w/ stock cams
All three motors have V-AFC, OBD-1 conversion w/ Skunk2 ECU
All three motors have exhaust(GReddy on 1 & 2, RSR on 3), and all have test pipes.
Results are surprising.
Lemme know if you want it.
Trying to draw any conclusions from that mess is kind of silly, don't you think?
Kinda... but it's interesting either way.
I've got something similar but all run on the same dyno.
1- ITR motor w/ CTR pistons, JDM 4-1 and Skunk2 cams
2- ITR motor w/ ITR pistons, DC JDM and stock cams
3- ITR motor w/ ITR pistons, DC JDM and ported head w/ stock cams
All three motors have V-AFC, OBD-1 conversion w/ Skunk2 ECU
All three motors have exhaust(GReddy on 1 & 2, RSR on 3), and all have test pipes.
Results are surprising.
Lemme know if you want it.
Kinda... but it's interesting either way.
I've got something similar but all run on the same dyno.
1- ITR motor w/ CTR pistons, JDM 4-1 and Skunk2 cams
2- ITR motor w/ ITR pistons, DC JDM and stock cams
3- ITR motor w/ ITR pistons, DC JDM and ported head w/ stock cams
All three motors have V-AFC, OBD-1 conversion w/ Skunk2 ECU
All three motors have exhaust(GReddy on 1 & 2, RSR on 3), and all have test pipes.
Results are surprising.
Lemme know if you want it.
CB
Here is some more to think about. Vago re-dynoed his car at the area 51 dyno day on th 20th. I was not there, but he has put plenty of miles on his car and it is getting broken in by this time, here are the numbers he sent me from that day. The only changes are a new car sound cat, his random cat fell apart and we installed a resonator to help with the sound. I'm sure Vago will verify these numbers.
RPM torque Hp
5,000 122 117
5,500 120 126
6,000 137 157
6,500 129 158
7,000 129 170
7,500 130 185
8,000 127 189
You can draw your own conclusions.
In a few weeks we will be running a new blueprinted 2000 Type R race motor. It is a stock Type R, but we went through it and cleaned up the head, changed the rods and pistons to better units, and a few more tricks. It will have new exhaust that we will be trying on it. The only other upgrade is a Mugen ECU. I will post the numbers when we run the car.
RPM torque Hp
5,000 122 117
5,500 120 126
6,000 137 157
6,500 129 158
7,000 129 170
7,500 130 185
8,000 127 189
You can draw your own conclusions.
In a few weeks we will be running a new blueprinted 2000 Type R race motor. It is a stock Type R, but we went through it and cleaned up the head, changed the rods and pistons to better units, and a few more tricks. It will have new exhaust that we will be trying on it. The only other upgrade is a Mugen ECU. I will post the numbers when we run the car.
doesn't dyno'ing in the 3rd gear or 4th gear make a diff? I'm not sure what gear andy or the comptech did there's on, but at Area51 they were doing 3rd gear pulls.
yoshi - who wasn't sure *shrugs*
yoshi - who wasn't sure *shrugs*
All cars are running stock TBs, intakes and cams - how can they possibly differ that much in terms of air flow (cfm)? Airflow and fuel determine power right?
In a few weeks we will be running a new blueprinted 2000 Type R race motor. It is a stock Type R, but we went through it and cleaned up the head, changed the rods and pistons to better units, and a few more tricks. It will have new exhaust that we will be trying on it. The only other upgrade is a Mugen ECU. I will post the numbers when we run the car.
Warren
In a few weeks we will be running a new blueprinted 2000 Type R race motor. It is a stock Type R, but we went through it and cleaned up the head, changed the rods and pistons to better units, and a few more tricks. It will have new exhaust that we will be trying on it. The only other upgrade is a Mugen ECU. I will post the numbers when we run the car.
Uh... rods and pistons are NOT what I consider minor changes.
Warren
Uh... rods and pistons are NOT what I consider minor changes.
Warren
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
fastfour
All Motor / Naturally Aspirated
11
Jan 9, 2005 07:07 PM
97itr86
Honda Civic / Del Sol (1992 - 2000)
15
Mar 18, 2003 06:32 PM
hYpE-R-29
Acura Integra Type-R
14
Nov 15, 2002 08:33 AM
RR98ITR
Road Racing / Autocross & Time Attack
3
Jul 1, 2002 02:59 PM








