Boost vs. HP vs Sleeves
#1
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Boost vs. HP vs Sleeves
Can you please help me on making clear one point ?
There's an ls/vtec engine with two options: (for example)
1. gtx2863r turbo, 20 psi boost, 350 HP
2. T3 60-1turbo, 12 psi boost, 350 HP
if the rest of the engine is the same, do these two setups create the same amount of stress on engine sleeves ?
thanks..
There's an ls/vtec engine with two options: (for example)
1. gtx2863r turbo, 20 psi boost, 350 HP
2. T3 60-1turbo, 12 psi boost, 350 HP
if the rest of the engine is the same, do these two setups create the same amount of stress on engine sleeves ?
thanks..
#3
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (7)
Join Date: Nov 2010
Location: 704
Posts: 808
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Boost vs. HP vs Sleeves
The way I've understood it (this amount of air)+(this amount of fuel)=(this horsepower). So just because they are running a differant psi its still the same volume of air. Look at how much boost the EVO guys have to throw @ their setups to achieve the same horsepower as a Honda with the same turbo. Hondas are more efficient flow wise so I might take 20psi with (x) turbo to reach (x) HP and 35psi to due the same thing on an EVO. I'm sure someone has a more technical answer but thats my understanding of it.
#5
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Tampa, FL
Posts: 327
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Boost vs. HP vs Sleeves
If engines are the same, take the cfm of each turbo and use that to determine your answer.
You can also use the efficiency charts made by the turbo manufacturer to determine if the smaller of the 2 is outside its efficiency range. A turbo operating outside its range may cause more stress than a larger unit blowing colder air.
You can also use the efficiency charts made by the turbo manufacturer to determine if the smaller of the 2 is outside its efficiency range. A turbo operating outside its range may cause more stress than a larger unit blowing colder air.
#6
Moderator
iTrader: (14)
Re: Boost vs. HP vs Sleeves
If engines are the same, take the cfm of each turbo and use that to determine your answer.
You can also use the efficiency charts made by the turbo manufacturer to determine if the smaller of the 2 is outside its efficiency range. A turbo operating outside its range may cause more stress than a larger unit blowing colder air.
You can also use the efficiency charts made by the turbo manufacturer to determine if the smaller of the 2 is outside its efficiency range. A turbo operating outside its range may cause more stress than a larger unit blowing colder air.
the problem that specifically the Honda world has is the notion that most believe that if they get the same "peak power" desired from a dyno at a low boost pressure, that they're being efficient and have lower cylinder pressures than one that uses a bit more pressure within the efficient part of the "island". Cylinder pressure is cylinder pressure. Whether you're running 8psi or 18psi, your engine is either going to be able to handle it with the internal components inside, or it won't (within reason, of course). there's nothing wrong with 2-3 more psi of boost pressure to be within in the better part of the island and have a much better "powerband" than some peak number.
To simply say "I'm using a 6262 at 12psi on a stock block" is not efficient. It just means the stock block is handling the same cylinder pressures as one that's using a couple more psi of boost pressure with a smaller turbo, and the smaller turbo is actually more fun, because its not as "laggy" as the larger one.
I'll take a Surfer or Predator at 5-8psi more, and stomp the monkey out of that 6262 because I'm using 4000-8000rpms, and not just 7000-8500 where the 6262 would just START to get efficient.
Same goes with people wanting 450whp w/ 91 octane on a 1.8-2.2 litre. you may not get the highest "peak power", but you'll have a better powerband with 50whp less, and wipe out the "peak power" person.
Last edited by TheShodan; 06-23-2013 at 05:51 PM.
Trending Topics
#12
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (2)
Re: Boost vs. HP vs Sleeves
You also have to look at the torque number as well. The smaller turbo will make boost faster and produce more torque in the lower rpm range. The cylinder pressure could very well be higher than the larger turbo that makes less torque but carries it out farther.
#13
Moderator
iTrader: (14)
Re: Boost vs. HP vs Sleeves
Absolutely.. And if the cylinder pressures are slightly higher, its really to the point to where the engine will either handle boost or it won't. You've either built the car for turbocharging or you haven't. cylinder pressures would be more of a constant, not a variable.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post