Critique my welds, MIG.
If anything looks wrong please tell me where I screwed up. Im not sure how much you can judge on flat welds, but any advise is better than none. This is my first time using my new mig (Lincoln 180).



Shaded region was not me.



Shaded region was not me.
Yeah I figured that was one of the problems. (the scrap had some heavy duty coating on it)
Are the marks throughout most of the welds contamination?
Are the marks throughout most of the welds contamination?
chances are you will need to go a little straighter but overall it looks fine for just making little worms or whatever those are. The coating it called mill scale. It's going to be on any hot rolled stock you get.
<TABLE WIDTH="90%" CELLSPACING=0 CELLPADDING=0 ALIGN=CENTER><TR><TD>Quote, originally posted by The Destroyer »</TD></TR><TR><TD CLASS="quote">Yeah I figured that was one of the problems. (the scrap had some heavy duty coating on it)
Are the marks throughout most of the welds contamination?</TD></TR></TABLE>
yeah. mig has little more slop then tig all the time though. if you take off that coating it will weld super nice.
Are the marks throughout most of the welds contamination?</TD></TR></TABLE>
yeah. mig has little more slop then tig all the time though. if you take off that coating it will weld super nice.
<TABLE WIDTH="90%" CELLSPACING=0 CELLPADDING=0 ALIGN=CENTER><TR><TD>Quote, originally posted by Bailhatch »</TD></TR><TR><TD CLASS="quote">chances are you will need to go a little straighter but overall it looks fine for just making little worms or whatever those are. The coating it called mill scale. It's going to be on any hot rolled stock you get.</TD></TR></TABLE>
This was scrap from a shed, it had some sort of heavy paint on it. Ill try going straighter, I was more focused on a consistent puddle.
This was scrap from a shed, it had some sort of heavy paint on it. Ill try going straighter, I was more focused on a consistent puddle.
doesnt look too bad for your first time welding though mill scale. The scale wont let the puddle spread out like it will on clean steel so I usually end up whipping the gun a bit in a forward/backward motion with a setup a tiny bit heavy on the volts. You dont have to have a really pronounced whip either. Something like 1-2 wire widths long at most. Try scribing some cheat lines so you have something to follow while you are learning to make imaginary straight lines.
Trending Topics
it's galvanized that's REALLY bad for you not aluminized..although I can't imagine it's that great for you lungs.
Learn to weld flat first and work you way down to thinner flat stock. Once you can do that properly then work with some tubing.
You have a metal scrap yard near you? They charge by the lb no matter what configuration the scrap is in. It's a fantastic way to get a variety of thicknesses and shapes to practice on.
Learn to weld flat first and work you way down to thinner flat stock. Once you can do that properly then work with some tubing.
You have a metal scrap yard near you? They charge by the lb no matter what configuration the scrap is in. It's a fantastic way to get a variety of thicknesses and shapes to practice on.
<TABLE WIDTH="90%" CELLSPACING=0 CELLPADDING=0 ALIGN=CENTER><TR><TD>Quote, originally posted by The Destroyer »</TD></TR><TR><TD CLASS="quote">

Shaded region was not me.
</TD></TR></TABLE>
Sure it wasn't.
First picture looks like some undercut and porosity. Second one looks better but like everyone else said you won't really know till you weld some joints together.

Shaded region was not me.
</TD></TR></TABLE>Sure it wasn't.
First picture looks like some undercut and porosity. Second one looks better but like everyone else said you won't really know till you weld some joints together.
<TABLE WIDTH="90%" CELLSPACING=0 CELLPADDING=0 ALIGN=CENTER><TR><TD>Quote, originally posted by slideshow240 »</TD></TR><TR><TD CLASS="quote">not the best i have seen, im guessing thats short arc or is it fluxcore? if thats your first time not bad. and it looks like your going kind of slow with your weaves, looks kind of built up.</TD></TR></TABLE>
short arc or fluxcore???? DO you mean short circuit transfer? Also he says it's mig right in the title not fluxcore. He isn't weaving either, he is just doing straight beads. When doing beads on flat piece they always look a little built up and lumpy.
short arc or fluxcore???? DO you mean short circuit transfer? Also he says it's mig right in the title not fluxcore. He isn't weaving either, he is just doing straight beads. When doing beads on flat piece they always look a little built up and lumpy.
oooh, I'm going to tell on you...
I prefer the drinking, at least it gets rid of my shaky hands..
The indo just makes me afraid of the welder, I want to go into a corner and hide
:disclaimer: Don't listen to anything I say...ever...about anything ...even welding. :disclaimer:
MJ gives this whiteboy more rythem baby!
:disclaimer: Don't listen to anything I say...ever...about anything ...even welding. :disclaimer:
Micheal Jackson was so awesome back in the day. Billie Jean is not my lover unph she's just a girl who says that I am the one but the kid is not my son.
K I'll stop I have to go to work now. 3rd shift rocks.
MJ gives this whiteboy more rythem baby!

:disclaimer: Don't listen to anything I say...ever...about anything ...even welding. :disclaimer:
Micheal Jackson was so awesome back in the day. Billie Jean is not my lover unph she's just a girl who says that I am the one but the kid is not my son.
K I'll stop I have to go to work now. 3rd shift rocks.
It is not flux, it is normal wire and have the tank set to 15cfh. Iv used flux in the past and it had so much more spatter. With this I *think* I have the gas settings right because of the miniscule spatter?




