Well, my front bumper broke, so I got a new one, it's plastic feeling, or think thats what it is. My car is Cypress Green Pearl, if I get it painted will the outcome be the same as the rest of the car?

 

it should be if your painter paint matches your car. it may look a little bit brighter then the rest of your car.

 

Bumpers usually don't match the rest of the car, even straight from the factory. Some paint formulas will match dead nuts, and some won't. It's basically all about the painter, if he takes his time and tints it right, it will be close. If you just mix it and spray it, it's gonna be hit or miss.