Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
#1
Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
I've been troubleshooting my 1999 Honda Civic D16y8 5spd for while now. It had the typical Honda surging idle when I took possession of it. Now I'm at the point where it doesn't surge (or rarely does) but does have a high idle.
On cold starts, it idles between 1300-1500rpms for a while before settling down, which can take quite a while (engine at operating temp.)
Things I've done :
New IACV and bled coolant
Plugs and wires
Distributer and engine timed correctly
Test coolant temp sensor w/ multimeter. All good
Test TPS with multimeter. All good
Idle relearn procedure. But maybe it wasn't done correctly? I followed the Haynes manual. It's possible I missed a step.
Checked for vacuum leaks using carb cleaner. All good. But MAYBE I missed something here.
Is there anything else I can look to? I know the idle should be higher on cold starts but should settle down shortly thereafter. Seems only when engine has been driven and properly warmed does it idle within spec.
The ONLY thing I can come up with is the idle relearn wasn't done correctly or didn't take or there's a vacuum leak I missed with the carb cleaner. Curious your thoughts on this common Honda problem
On cold starts, it idles between 1300-1500rpms for a while before settling down, which can take quite a while (engine at operating temp.)
Things I've done :
New IACV and bled coolant
Plugs and wires
Distributer and engine timed correctly
Test coolant temp sensor w/ multimeter. All good
Test TPS with multimeter. All good
Idle relearn procedure. But maybe it wasn't done correctly? I followed the Haynes manual. It's possible I missed a step.
Checked for vacuum leaks using carb cleaner. All good. But MAYBE I missed something here.
Is there anything else I can look to? I know the idle should be higher on cold starts but should settle down shortly thereafter. Seems only when engine has been driven and properly warmed does it idle within spec.
The ONLY thing I can come up with is the idle relearn wasn't done correctly or didn't take or there's a vacuum leak I missed with the carb cleaner. Curious your thoughts on this common Honda problem
Last edited by D16HighMileage; 01-16-2020 at 01:49 PM.
#2
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
So, I don't have an answer. I only have an experience. I have driven my my 1998 D16y7 engine for 19 years daily (273,000+ miles on it). What you describe seems like normal operation to me. And in the Honda FSM you often get instructions to warm the car up until the cooling fan comes on before testing or setting one thing or another (like ignition timing). I think you did some great maintainance, but I am not sure there is a problem. Someone correct me.
The following users liked this post:
#3
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
Although this is my 1st Honda and what got me into them, it seems the idle should settle down quite a bit earlier. I suppose you could consider this : it is a 20 year old engine with 202,000 miles. I guess the only way I'll know for sure if this is "normal" would be starting the engine when it's 100° outside. I'll have to wait several months for that as I'm in NH.
I'd say confidently the idle is "a bit off". Like I mentioned, it was surging before (typical Honda thing) and now it primarily just idles high. I feel somethings amiss.
One test I can't recall if I performed was covering the throttle body while running to see if the engine chokes out and stalls. I'll be going this tomorrow.
I'd say confidently the idle is "a bit off". Like I mentioned, it was surging before (typical Honda thing) and now it primarily just idles high. I feel somethings amiss.
One test I can't recall if I performed was covering the throttle body while running to see if the engine chokes out and stalls. I'll be going this tomorrow.
The following users liked this post:
#4
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
I would watch your temp gauge to see whether the engine warms up slower than normal. If so, you may need to replace the thermostat.
The following users liked this post:
#5
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
Would the thermostat cause a higher than normal idle? I've never had overhearing issues. But taking longer than normal to reach operating temperature is something I hadn't considered yet. I'm aware a failed coolant temp sensor can cause idle issues since it'll send incorrect signals to the ECU.
The following users liked this post:
#6
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
Would the thermostat cause a higher than normal idle? I've never had overhearing issues. But taking longer than normal to reach operating temperature is something I hadn't considered yet. I'm aware a failed coolant temp sensor can cause idle issues since it'll send incorrect signals to the ECU.
The following users liked this post:
Trending Topics
#8
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
2 things I haven't checked yet :
1) The idle control screw. It's possible it's not adjusted properly. I've only recently purchased this vehicle.
2) Possible bad head gasket? I haven't checked the coolant for exhaust gasses but I'll be doing this soon.
So could a bad head gasket really cause surging idle and high idling?
Seems it was idling fairly well last week, although it did take a while for the idle to settle down. It idles high until reaching operating temp.
First up is the thermostat
Last edited by D16HighMileage; 01-18-2020 at 04:13 AM.
The following users liked this post:
#9
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
Any CEL codes associated with the idle problems?
Regarding the surging, do this simple test:
Regarding the surging, do this simple test:
- Warm up the engine.
- Remove air intake system.
- Start engine.
- With the idle surging, use your finger to cover the IACV bypass hole (upper port) inside the throttle.
- Does the surging stop?
The following users liked this post:
#10
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
[QUOTE=muellersfan;52088128]Any CEL codes associated with the idle problems?
Regarding the surging, do this simple test:
No CEL. How I bled coolant system was to put a funnel in the radiator cap and allow all air bubbles to escape. I did not loosen the bleeder screw however. Do the D16y8 's have this bleeder screw? I didn't notice.
I will be performing the test mentioned above tonight and report back shortly I'm stumped as of now but I'm hopeful it's a simple oversight (possibly still air in the cooling system)
Regarding the surging, do this simple test:
- Warm up the engine.
- Remove air intake system.
- Start engine.
- With the idle surging, use your finger to cover the IACV bypass hole (upper port) inside the throttle.
- Does the surging stop?
No CEL. How I bled coolant system was to put a funnel in the radiator cap and allow all air bubbles to escape. I did not loosen the bleeder screw however. Do the D16y8 's have this bleeder screw? I didn't notice.
I will be performing the test mentioned above tonight and report back shortly I'm stumped as of now but I'm hopeful it's a simple oversight (possibly still air in the cooling system)
The following users liked this post:
#11
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
Bleeding:
Your engine lacks a bleeder valve.
Turn heater all the way to max heat. No need to turn on blower.
Top off radiator with coolant.
Loosen radiator cap one turn.
Idle engine until radiator fan turns on twice.
Top off radiator and reservoir.
Your engine lacks a bleeder valve.
Turn heater all the way to max heat. No need to turn on blower.
Top off radiator with coolant.
Loosen radiator cap one turn.
Idle engine until radiator fan turns on twice.
Top off radiator and reservoir.
Last edited by muellersfan; 01-18-2020 at 02:05 PM.
The following users liked this post:
The following 2 users liked this post by 94 Civic Si:
#13
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
This method^ is preferred by many members, but following the method detailed in the service manual has always worked for me without making the additional funnel purchase.
The following 2 users liked this post by muellersfan:
#14
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
I still have, what I mentioned in the 1st thread, as a slightly higher than "usual" cold start idle where is also takes a bit longer than "normal" to settle down. Temps are freezing in my area lately (5-15° in the mornings). I'm putting in a new thermostat shortly to see if that has any effect. I've tested the TPS and CTS and all check out there.
The following 2 users liked this post by D16HighMileage:
#15
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
This^ likely explains the higher than normal cold-engine idle speed. Hopefully replacing the thermostat will shorten the engine warm up time. I would recommend that you purchase the thermostat from the Honda dealer.
The following users liked this post:
The following users liked this post:
#17
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
I fixed my idle surge after trying 3 different iacv it was a pain because I kept checking everything took me about a month to figure out it was the iacv and to try different ones
#18
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
Did you use a Genuine Honda IACV? I used a Genuine Honda IACV and have no worries it's not performing 100% as it should. As mentioned, it's critical to burp the cooling system properly to remove all air bubbles. I thought I had but it turns out I still had some air in the system.
#19
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
Did you use a Genuine Honda IACV? I used a Genuine Honda IACV and have no worries it's not performing 100% as it should. As mentioned, it's critical to burp the cooling system properly to remove all air bubbles. I thought I had but it turns out I still had some air in the system.
The following users liked this post:
#20
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
ya I had too use the OEM IACV I did not wanna spend the 200 and something dollars but now I know that aftermarket ones don’t really work I tried two one from pepboys and one from autozone till I bought the OEM because I was tired of wasting time with it as soon as I put OEM I bleed the coolant and it was running perfect right at 800 rpm
The following 3 users liked this post by muellersfan:
#21
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
ya I did do that with the original iacv but cleaning it didn’t work so I went to pepboy bought one and AutoZone one then when they didn’t work someone told me to get a new OEM and put it on it went on my B16A2 and as soon as I put it on it worked flawlessly I think the ones from part store are for automatics but it say it works for Manuel’s so I think there’s a problem with the parts stores IACV
#22
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
I don't know if this is the right place, but I have a 92 si with a d16z6, the idle surges after a minute or so and won't stop. There's no vacuum leaks, the coolant has been bled, I did the bleed procedure 3 times to be sure, it has a brand new tstat and a brand new fitv, I've ruled out the iacv, I've multimeter tested the tps and o2 sensor, I have no clue what it might be.
#23
Re: Typical surging idle/hunting idle and high idle
I don't know if this is the right place, but I have a 92 si with a d16z6, the idle surges after a minute or so and won't stop. There's no vacuum leaks, the coolant has been bled, I did the bleed procedure 3 times to be sure, it has a brand new tstat and a brand new fitv, I've ruled out the iacv, I've multimeter tested the tps and o2 sensor, I have no clue what it might be.
#25
The following users liked this post: