Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
#1
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: South, TX
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
I had an incident with my new engine and I am seeking advice on where to go from here.
I was advised by my shop to run high compression pistons to keep my low RPM power and also spool the turbo quicker. He said that it is recently common practice run forced induction engines with these specs.
B20VTEC
84.5MM Supertech pistons 11.5/1CR
Gt3076R
ID2000 injectors
Premium pump 93 octane
Tuning was going along but not great. My wastegate turned out to have a 16LB spring set in it. I was told this was making tuning difficult. He was able to tune the low RPM cam but when it crossed over to vtec we were either too rich or too lean and he would abort the run. Eventually he figured out "acceptable maps and settings" to cross over into vtec and did 2 WOT runs. At this point I noticed a coolant leak from the radiator cap. We checked the cap and the coolant level and all seemed ok. On the third WOT run the lower radiator hose was completely blown off the block and I suspected the head gasket had let go.
When I got home I pulled the plugs and saw a tiny bit of coolant in cylinder 3. I then pulled the head to replace the head gasket and noticed the piston damage.
I see my options as follows:
1. Replace all of the pistons with 9.5/1 CR and run premium gas.
2. Replace the damaged piston with another 11.5/1 CR piston and run lower boost and or use E85 fuel.
3. Determine that damage to the piston is only superficial and run my current piston set at lower boost settings and or E85 fuel.
Please look at the pics and tell me what you think should be done. Thanks!
I was advised by my shop to run high compression pistons to keep my low RPM power and also spool the turbo quicker. He said that it is recently common practice run forced induction engines with these specs.
B20VTEC
84.5MM Supertech pistons 11.5/1CR
Gt3076R
ID2000 injectors
Premium pump 93 octane
Tuning was going along but not great. My wastegate turned out to have a 16LB spring set in it. I was told this was making tuning difficult. He was able to tune the low RPM cam but when it crossed over to vtec we were either too rich or too lean and he would abort the run. Eventually he figured out "acceptable maps and settings" to cross over into vtec and did 2 WOT runs. At this point I noticed a coolant leak from the radiator cap. We checked the cap and the coolant level and all seemed ok. On the third WOT run the lower radiator hose was completely blown off the block and I suspected the head gasket had let go.
When I got home I pulled the plugs and saw a tiny bit of coolant in cylinder 3. I then pulled the head to replace the head gasket and noticed the piston damage.
I see my options as follows:
1. Replace all of the pistons with 9.5/1 CR and run premium gas.
2. Replace the damaged piston with another 11.5/1 CR piston and run lower boost and or use E85 fuel.
3. Determine that damage to the piston is only superficial and run my current piston set at lower boost settings and or E85 fuel.
Please look at the pics and tell me what you think should be done. Thanks!
#2
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
Running 11.5CR piston at 16psi with 93 octane is a recipe for detonation. It's E85 territory. If you have access to E85 then use it. If not then go lower compression (below 10CR). It would be best to take out all pistons to inspect for damage.
#3
Moderator in Chief
iTrader: (2)
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
I agree. I'm not sure why your tuner thought pump gasoline was adequate with that much compression and boost. Plus the compression helps spool is nonsense. I cannot believe they tried to tune that with a 16psi spring. So many red flags here.
Trending Topics
#8
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
16psi on a 3076? With a stock sleeve b20??? Sounds like you are more lucky that you only had a little piston damage...
How much power are you trying to make? Obviously 16psi is too much for your setup. I think you could stay 11.5:1, but I would go down to a MAX 10psi spring. Maybe even 8. Even at that you should be well over 300whp, which is still well past the comfort zone of stock b20 sleeves...
How much power are you trying to make? Obviously 16psi is too much for your setup. I think you could stay 11.5:1, but I would go down to a MAX 10psi spring. Maybe even 8. Even at that you should be well over 300whp, which is still well past the comfort zone of stock b20 sleeves...
#9
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
16psi on a 3076? With a stock sleeve b20??? Sounds like you are more lucky that you only had a little piston damage...
How much power are you trying to make? Obviously 16psi is too much for your setup. I think you could stay 11.5:1, but I would go down to a MAX 10psi spring. Maybe even 8. Even at that you should be well over 300whp, which is still well past the comfort zone of stock b20 sleeves...
How much power are you trying to make? Obviously 16psi is too much for your setup. I think you could stay 11.5:1, but I would go down to a MAX 10psi spring. Maybe even 8. Even at that you should be well over 300whp, which is still well past the comfort zone of stock b20 sleeves...
#10
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: South, TX
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
My block is Benson sleeved. I agree that the tuner doesn't seem to be competent and I will be taking my car to a tuner in Houston next time. The engine produced 440WHP and 319WTQ on the last dyno run. I am wanting to stay above 400WPH with this engine when it's all said and done. I have already re-arranged my spring set in the waste gate to bring the gate pressure to 9LBS.
Thanks for the replies.
Thanks for the replies.
#13
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
If you read the OP he stated one of his options would be using lower compression pistons, so AZ CIVIC was informing him of his setup and verifying that it would work just fine.
#14
I never narc'd on nobody!
iTrader: (1)
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
And you don't know what little man syndrome is, if you think it in any way applies here. Raising compression is not about power at the top of the band. Raising compression is all about raising power UNDER the band. Higher compression, better torque curve, better power before boost. Simple as that.
#15
Retired Moderator
iTrader: (8)
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
Dayum.
pump gas on 11.5 is fine.. But adding boost on top
Its not the tuners fault you decided to run pump gas with your set up. this shop shouldve advised you, but they mightve figured you werent using pump gas..
Its the tuners fault for trying to tune it with pump gas in it. He should know better *if he knew wtf he was doing
Like stated before, Run a 8-10lb spring, and personally with this kind of power, I would run an EBC.
pump gas on 11.5 is fine.. But adding boost on top
Its not the tuners fault you decided to run pump gas with your set up. this shop shouldve advised you, but they mightve figured you werent using pump gas..
Its the tuners fault for trying to tune it with pump gas in it. He should know better *if he knew wtf he was doing
Like stated before, Run a 8-10lb spring, and personally with this kind of power, I would run an EBC.
#16
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
like I said. Im talking about you and your attitude. No need to treat people like **** for helping right? There ins't anything wrong with lower comp pistons and boost. No it doesn't fit your theory but that doesn't mean it doesn't work or isn't correct. Obviously his setup wasn't correct for what he was doing. A better tuner would have said no more on the fuel you're using or figured it out. Still, would you appreciate some **** *** attitude coming your way? most likley not
#19
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: South, TX
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
I am running an EBC. I do have access to E85 fuel also and I think I will go with that. The shop that helped my build this engine did specifically say that it would work with premium pump gas! And it might have with much lower boost. I should have done a lot more research before I went ahead and took his advice at face value. And the tuner should have been knowledgeable enough to avoid tuning with unsafe conditions. Sometimes we learn the hard way.
So Is there any way this piston could still be used? All of the other pistons appeared to be undamaged. I really am considering just assembling the engine with a new gasket and head studs and filling it up with E-85. Too risky?
So Is there any way this piston could still be used? All of the other pistons appeared to be undamaged. I really am considering just assembling the engine with a new gasket and head studs and filling it up with E-85. Too risky?
#20
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
well you're missing a chunk of piston if I see that correctly? Also it has made some change in the cylinder wall so you can imagine it would only become a bigger issue down the road.
#21
I never narc'd on nobody!
iTrader: (1)
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
I am running an EBC. I do have access to E85 fuel also and I think I will go with that. The shop that helped my build this engine did specifically say that it would work with premium pump gas! And it might have with much lower boost. I should have done a lot more research before I went ahead and took his advice at face value. And the tuner should have been knowledgeable enough to avoid tuning with unsafe conditions. Sometimes we learn the hard way.
So Is there any way this piston could still be used? All of the other pistons appeared to be undamaged. I really am considering just assembling the engine with a new gasket and head studs and filling it up with E-85. Too risky?
So Is there any way this piston could still be used? All of the other pistons appeared to be undamaged. I really am considering just assembling the engine with a new gasket and head studs and filling it up with E-85. Too risky?
If you already have ARP head studs, you shouldn't need to replace them. Gasket is obviously up for replacement. As for the piston, I would take it out and have it inspected professionally. There might be damage you can't see, and that damage will absolutely **** on you if it decides to give out.
I don't know about B20 sleeves being limited to 300, but you should definitely get a lighter spring and take it to a real professional to have it done properly.
#22
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: South, TX
Posts: 68
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
It seemed like the tuner was just "throwing numbers" at my ECU. I'm no tuner either and I know that someone who has more tuning knowledge than I do is not necessarily qualified.
At the time of tuning neither I or the tuner knew that Tial had spring sets. I thought it was one spring in there. So we thought we couldn't lower the boost.
On a side note this is the second time I have had leaky head gaskets when reusing ARP head studs. On two separate engine builds I have had one time used ARP head studs not seal the head gasket. I followed all the cleaning and lubricant requirements and torque specs. Happened twice.
Also my block is sleeved so no sleeve issues for me.
At the time of tuning neither I or the tuner knew that Tial had spring sets. I thought it was one spring in there. So we thought we couldn't lower the boost.
On a side note this is the second time I have had leaky head gaskets when reusing ARP head studs. On two separate engine builds I have had one time used ARP head studs not seal the head gasket. I followed all the cleaning and lubricant requirements and torque specs. Happened twice.
Also my block is sleeved so no sleeve issues for me.
#23
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (1)
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
Secondly yes the guy did mention that he was thinking about using lower compression pistons and I was just letting him know that he can use lower compression and still get nice low end power. But what would I know LOL.
#24
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
Well, the Supertech pistons you are using is made of forged 4032 aluminum, so it is a little less tolerant to detonation. This means some of the pistons skirt could have been stressed too much and just waiting to fail. It's called metal fatigue and it can be very hard to predict the failure. If the skirt fails you going to end up with a free rod waiting to punch new holes through the block.
Now, sometimes people might want to save time or money by skipping steps but if any pistons fail, be prepared to start over again... Time and money.
E85 is a very good fuel but you will also need a very good tuner. Also, I always do a compression test before tuning any high hp set up. This gives me a good indication of the engine and helps me decide if I should tune or not.
Now, sometimes people might want to save time or money by skipping steps but if any pistons fail, be prepared to start over again... Time and money.
E85 is a very good fuel but you will also need a very good tuner. Also, I always do a compression test before tuning any high hp set up. This gives me a good indication of the engine and helps me decide if I should tune or not.
#25
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Forced Induction Detonation Damage?
Don't worry the dude is an idiot, you don't need high compression to gain low end power when you're using a gt3076r turbo. That turbo is small and will spool very quick on its own.
Secondly yes the guy did mention that he was thinking about using lower compression pistons and I was just letting him know that he can use lower compression and still get nice low end power. But what would I know LOL.
Secondly yes the guy did mention that he was thinking about using lower compression pistons and I was just letting him know that he can use lower compression and still get nice low end power. But what would I know LOL.