H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
#102
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Chicago, IL, USA
Posts: 3,348
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
#105
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Nov 2004
Location: Lecce, Italia
Posts: 53
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
i have some pics yes...the current 11.3 was at 338whp on a type s base lude....i have a g23 based set-up that has perty much all the parts need too make raceable but has an oil pressure issue so i havent got any new numbers....thanks for the props....will be working on the car again next year..im from iowa and are racing season is over..
pics at
************.com/forums/showthread.php?t=305852&highlight=goldluderay&page =28
and
************.com/forums/showthread.php?t=305852&highlight=goldluderay&page =26
************.com/forums/showthread.php?t=305852&highlight=goldluderay&page =23
put ..... p r e l u d e p o w e r in with out the space
pics at
************.com/forums/showthread.php?t=305852&highlight=goldluderay&page =28
and
************.com/forums/showthread.php?t=305852&highlight=goldluderay&page =26
************.com/forums/showthread.php?t=305852&highlight=goldluderay&page =23
put ..... p r e l u d e p o w e r in with out the space
Is your header a real old RMF?Or it is a new production (made by whom?)
#106
B*a*n*n*e*d
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Pensacola, FL
Posts: 1,538
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#107
#108
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Sin City
Posts: 811
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
bisi's greatest skill is hype marketing, not product design. he really knows how to get all the young impressionable kids all giddy over products. spaghetti headers, nothing new. rage racing was doing those years before bisi was and guess who was making them? randy monroe, also known as RMF.
it's all a big joke.
it's all a big joke.
#110
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
i think what you ment was...rmf once had headers that were based on the same design...bisi will sometimes say there headers are one off and not copyed...a smart person will tell you allmost all header's design have been copyed...headers have been around for along time you can only bend them so many different ways
#111
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: 161822, ca, L.A.
Posts: 1,026
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
This thread proved absolutely nothing except that a properly manipulated "test" could sway a crowd. Why is there is no overlay of all 3 headers or air fuel ratios? And the video shows them all within ~1hp of each other at the top. The mid range dip that you claim existed but never proved with an overlay could have to do with plenty of other variables. Things like the lack of an exhaust, tuning, crossover points, ignition timing and "fuel maps that looked similar" but could have been altered in between runs to make any of the products look more desirable.
I'm not picking sides and I don't own any of these headers but some of the people in this thread seem to have a vested interest in the sales and marketing of a specific header.
The comparison of track application headers to production headers clearly doesn't work either Julio, since package constraints limit what you can put under the hood of a street car and all of the headers on the posted drag cars are longer than the production units. The last video you posted shows a quick pull with no comparison to anything else either. I also understand that a pissing match isn't really something you're looking to get into from a business standpoint, especially with someone on the other end of the U.S.
That being said, there is also no evidence that any of the graphs shown in the test video are from the header they are claimed to be from, we have just your word and video editing to go by.
I'm not picking sides and I don't own any of these headers but some of the people in this thread seem to have a vested interest in the sales and marketing of a specific header.
The comparison of track application headers to production headers clearly doesn't work either Julio, since package constraints limit what you can put under the hood of a street car and all of the headers on the posted drag cars are longer than the production units. The last video you posted shows a quick pull with no comparison to anything else either. I also understand that a pissing match isn't really something you're looking to get into from a business standpoint, especially with someone on the other end of the U.S.
That being said, there is also no evidence that any of the graphs shown in the test video are from the header they are claimed to be from, we have just your word and video editing to go by.
#113
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Miami, FL
Posts: 444
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
This thread proved absolutely nothing except that a properly manipulated "test" could sway a crowd. Why is there is no overlay of all 3 headers or air fuel ratios? And the video shows them all within ~1hp of each other at the top. The mid range dip that you claim existed but never proved with an overlay could have to do with plenty of other variables. Things like the lack of an exhaust, tuning, crossover points, ignition timing and "fuel maps that looked similar" but could have been altered in between runs to make any of the products look more desirable.
I'm not picking sides and I don't own any of these headers but some of the people in this thread seem to have a vested interest in the sales and marketing of a specific header.
The comparison of track application headers to production headers clearly doesn't work either Julio, since package constraints limit what you can put under the hood of a street car and all of the headers on the posted drag cars are longer than the production units. The last video you posted shows a quick pull with no comparison to anything else either. I also understand that a pissing match isn't really something you're looking to get into from a business standpoint, especially with someone on the other end of the U.S.
That being said, there is also no evidence that any of the graphs shown in the test video are from the header they are claimed to be from, we have just your word and video editing to go by.
I'm not picking sides and I don't own any of these headers but some of the people in this thread seem to have a vested interest in the sales and marketing of a specific header.
The comparison of track application headers to production headers clearly doesn't work either Julio, since package constraints limit what you can put under the hood of a street car and all of the headers on the posted drag cars are longer than the production units. The last video you posted shows a quick pull with no comparison to anything else either. I also understand that a pissing match isn't really something you're looking to get into from a business standpoint, especially with someone on the other end of the U.S.
That being said, there is also no evidence that any of the graphs shown in the test video are from the header they are claimed to be from, we have just your word and video editing to go by.
I totally understand your point about not having everything laid out and people wanting to challenge the test, but in reality, people can challenge and cry about whatever they want, the only person who needed to believe the results was jaywest and this test showed him what he wanted to see.
#114
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: bronx, ny, usa
Posts: 1,464
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
all i wanna say is thanks for the test...they do help the sport...and consumers..when i bough my bisimoto i bought it for 3 reasons...
1.."custom"
2..the look
3..i have a 3 inch exhaust and wanted something to bolt up
according to what others have posted they have the same dimensions on 1.8l, and 2.0l so its not really custom...looks great so thats good specialy after it heats up and gets the ss gold look...
but the main reason i got it was so it could bolt to my exhaust which accordig to the sales rep it did...but i ended up having to buy a piece of pipe, a flexi and flanges..over 100 bucks cause i couldnt find a 3 inch donut kit...
for the 800 i paid they could at least had included the required donut and spring bolt kit..so it doesnt crack...
but im still hoping it makes decent power on my setup...if it does i dont care about the rest..
1.."custom"
2..the look
3..i have a 3 inch exhaust and wanted something to bolt up
according to what others have posted they have the same dimensions on 1.8l, and 2.0l so its not really custom...looks great so thats good specialy after it heats up and gets the ss gold look...
but the main reason i got it was so it could bolt to my exhaust which accordig to the sales rep it did...but i ended up having to buy a piece of pipe, a flexi and flanges..over 100 bucks cause i couldnt find a 3 inch donut kit...
for the 800 i paid they could at least had included the required donut and spring bolt kit..so it doesnt crack...
but im still hoping it makes decent power on my setup...if it does i dont care about the rest..
#115
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
if you have followed jaywest.....he wants too go fast...and he put the header on his car to help himself go faster...reguardless of brand or look...he put the header that he feels perform's the best on...he isnt influenced anyway other the his own personal et goals....
the thanks for the test results..look foward too seeing some new et's
the thanks for the test results..look foward too seeing some new et's
#116
All Motor Mentor
Join Date: Aug 2004
Location: 902, Nova Scotia, Canada
Posts: 6,987
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
I think the point being made here is that, if you want to test all this for yourselves so YOU all know the truth, that fine. If you want to SHARE all the information that you learned from the test by posting it here, there's a certain obligation to show ALL the graphs/charts/info etc so there is real benefit/tech etc and the thread doesn't end up in a pissing contest over it's validity.
I thought all the charts were going to be posted?
I thought all the charts were going to be posted?
#117
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
Understood, unfortunately i do not work at the shop or ever go there unless i need to dyno. If my tuner can get the graphs for me, great. If not, I'll be back on the dyno in the next few weeks.
I think it's one thing to ask for the overlays, its another to accuse someone of skewing the results because the overlays are not posted. As stated above, I have absolutely nothing to gain from posting the results of one companys product over another. I want to run whatever makes the most power for my setup. I chose to share it so others with similar setups can see the results and decide what products they might want to run. I know I should probably post every little detail about these tests, but realistically, once I do the test, it's almost just as much work to post these threads as it is to do the test in the first place.
Anyways, hopefully we will have them posted in the near future.
I think it's one thing to ask for the overlays, its another to accuse someone of skewing the results because the overlays are not posted. As stated above, I have absolutely nothing to gain from posting the results of one companys product over another. I want to run whatever makes the most power for my setup. I chose to share it so others with similar setups can see the results and decide what products they might want to run. I know I should probably post every little detail about these tests, but realistically, once I do the test, it's almost just as much work to post these threads as it is to do the test in the first place.
Anyways, hopefully we will have them posted in the near future.
#119
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
Jay West is gonna have another header to test this winter, it will be a TRUE custom header, not built for his own car but for a larger 90x95 setup. i think it will still be interesting to see how it performs against these other popular "custom" headers
good seeing u @ mir Jason, u know who this is...
good seeing u @ mir Jason, u know who this is...
#120
A Digital Frontier
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
Jay West is gonna have another header to test this winter, it will be a TRUE custom header, not built for his own car but for a larger 90x95 setup. i think it will still be interesting to see how it performs against these other popular "custom" headers
good seeing u @ mir Jason, u know who this is...
good seeing u @ mir Jason, u know who this is...
#121
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
Way too many variables, lets say your header makes the least power, and it is made by x. It will mislead people to believe x makes bad header's but in reality it is more than likely because of the size motor your header will be intended for. Unless you get other companies to make you a header intended for your 90x95, then right there you can take down all the variables. Good luck.
this is one of my headers meaning i made it and im ok if it performs subpar to the other headers tested since mine is not designed for a 87x90, id just like to see the data. even so i have a feeling it will hold its own, especially in the top of the powerband which is what its designed for...
Jason is a good candidate for testing my parts because he has a consistant drag car and a good tuner. they both know how to test parts correctly on the dyno. as for testing the header on the motor its designed for as well as larger motors, i have already done so myself and have all the data i need from larger displacement testing. im just curious to see what it will do on a stock bottom. i know it wont perform to its full potential since the primaries will be a bit to large as well as the collector but we will see how it does
#122
A Digital Frontier
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
That'd be interesting, id be down to stop by when they do another header test. It's always chill to hang at p2r and eat 5 guys right after lol.
#123
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Chicago, IL, USA
Posts: 3,348
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
Next time you're over at Sean's tell him i said wasup! Its been a while. I havent talked to him since we had dinner at Nasa Nationals a few years back.
#124
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Re: H2B Header Testing: RMF vs Bisi vs Logic
Jay West is gonna have another header to test this winter, it will be a TRUE custom header, not built for his own car but for a larger 90x95 setup. i think it will still be interesting to see how it performs against these other popular "custom" headers
good seeing u @ mir Jason, u know who this is...
good seeing u @ mir Jason, u know who this is...
Can't wait, I'm sure i'll be in the market for a new header after the test lol
#125
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter