Plummeting gas mileage
#1
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: SC
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Plummeting gas mileage
New problem, so I started a new thread.
I just got a new clutch, lightweight flywheel, ss clutch line, and ESMM inserts installed on my 2005 ep3. (I made a thread about that too, asking about labor prices.) The shop I used did great work for really cheap.
Anyways, I got everything installed 2.5 weeks ago, and my gas mileage has been horrible since. Before I had the work done, I averaged 305-315 miles per tank (mix of highway and city). Even on the low end, I was getting 24-25 mpg, usually about 27-28 (~12 gal. / 305 miles = 25.4 mpg)
I just filled up my tank on Friday: 225 miles driven since the last fill up, and I put ~12 gal. in the car, for a grand total of ~19 mpg. My driving style has not changed, I keep the tire pressure at 35psi, and oil/transmission fluid change ~1000 miles ago.
The only difference between my fuel economy a month ago to now is the new clutch, flywheel, ss clutch line and ESMM inserts. Would these mods lower my mpg?
I know they removed the sub-frame to install the clutch/flywheel, so could it be the alignment?
V6 mileage would be ok, so long as I got V6 power too, but with a k20a3 we know that's not the case.
As always, any help is appreciated.
I just got a new clutch, lightweight flywheel, ss clutch line, and ESMM inserts installed on my 2005 ep3. (I made a thread about that too, asking about labor prices.) The shop I used did great work for really cheap.
Anyways, I got everything installed 2.5 weeks ago, and my gas mileage has been horrible since. Before I had the work done, I averaged 305-315 miles per tank (mix of highway and city). Even on the low end, I was getting 24-25 mpg, usually about 27-28 (~12 gal. / 305 miles = 25.4 mpg)
I just filled up my tank on Friday: 225 miles driven since the last fill up, and I put ~12 gal. in the car, for a grand total of ~19 mpg. My driving style has not changed, I keep the tire pressure at 35psi, and oil/transmission fluid change ~1000 miles ago.
The only difference between my fuel economy a month ago to now is the new clutch, flywheel, ss clutch line and ESMM inserts. Would these mods lower my mpg?
I know they removed the sub-frame to install the clutch/flywheel, so could it be the alignment?
V6 mileage would be ok, so long as I got V6 power too, but with a k20a3 we know that's not the case.
As always, any help is appreciated.
#3
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
Disclaimer: I have no hard and fast experience with the OP's situation; just speculating here...
Given that all 4-Cylinder and 4-Stroke engines are "torque reversal" engines, and given that it is the rotational mass (aka. angular kinetic energy) stored in the flywheel is responsible for driving the engine during the (roughly) 40° period between when the current combustion stroke cylinder stops providing power to the crank and when the next combustion stroke cylinder starts providing power to the crank; theoretically (to my mind at least), if the flywheel is too light then the engine will slow down too much between power strokes (especially at lower engine speeds) and effectively mess up the timing of the peak pressure point of the combustion stroke (which is typically between 14° and 20° ATDC depending upon engine). If the peak pressure point comes too early (which I'm guessing is what is happening here) or too late, fuel economy will suffer.
Hmmm, reading what I just wrote, I'm thinking I might need to don my NOMEX suit and duck for cover.
Given that all 4-Cylinder and 4-Stroke engines are "torque reversal" engines, and given that it is the rotational mass (aka. angular kinetic energy) stored in the flywheel is responsible for driving the engine during the (roughly) 40° period between when the current combustion stroke cylinder stops providing power to the crank and when the next combustion stroke cylinder starts providing power to the crank; theoretically (to my mind at least), if the flywheel is too light then the engine will slow down too much between power strokes (especially at lower engine speeds) and effectively mess up the timing of the peak pressure point of the combustion stroke (which is typically between 14° and 20° ATDC depending upon engine). If the peak pressure point comes too early (which I'm guessing is what is happening here) or too late, fuel economy will suffer.
Hmmm, reading what I just wrote, I'm thinking I might need to don my NOMEX suit and duck for cover.
#4
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: SC
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
Paul, yes the CEL is on, but it's for the cat that I haven't replaced yet. When I replace the b-pipe, I'm gonna put a Magnaflow cat on there as well.
Shipo, the flywheel I had installed is 11lbs vs. ~14lbs stock. So yes, it is lighter, but would a 3lb reduction warrant a 5-6 mpg loss in economy?
Shipo, the flywheel I had installed is 11lbs vs. ~14lbs stock. So yes, it is lighter, but would a 3lb reduction warrant a 5-6 mpg loss in economy?
#5
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
Paul, yes the CEL is on, but it's for the cat that I haven't replaced yet. When I replace the b-pipe, I'm gonna put a Magnaflow cat on there as well.
Shipo, the flywheel I had installed is 11lbs vs. ~14lbs stock. So yes, it is lighter, but would a 3lb reduction warrant a 5-6 mpg loss in economy?
Shipo, the flywheel I had installed is 11lbs vs. ~14lbs stock. So yes, it is lighter, but would a 3lb reduction warrant a 5-6 mpg loss in economy?
Of course, given that we're talking about a flywheel containing a friction surface (which requires a pretty substantial amount of thermal mass/weight) for a clutch disk we know by definition that a significant portion of the mass isn't located at the outer perimeter. So, if the two flywheels have similar mass from the center out through the outer edge of the friction surface, and if the OEM flywheel has say three extra pounds located at the outer edge of the disk compared to the aftermarket unit you bought, then there will be a HUGE difference in the amount of energy stored at any given RPM.
Long story short, light weight flywheels are great for engines which spend their time on a track and are operated consistently in the upper RPM ranges; for a daily driver they're pretty worthless, IMHO.
Another thing to consider; Honda engineers are pretty darned smart, and they didn't just pull the weight (and more importantly the weight distribution) out of a hat, they did the calculus and determined what would be the optimal configuration (which by definition is always a compromise) for a car which will see both stop and go driving as well as high RPM operations.
Once again, the above is merely some (slightly) educated speculation; I've not done the math to actually prove what I've written.
#6
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
Long story short, light weight flywheels are great for engines which spend their time on a track and are operated consistently in the upper RPM ranges; for a daily driver they're pretty worthless, IMHO.
Another thing to consider; Honda engineers are pretty darned smart, and they didn't just pull the weight (and more importantly the weight distribution) out of a hat, they did the calculus and determined what would be the optimal configuration (which by definition is always a compromise) for a car which will see both stop and go driving as well as high RPM operations.
Another thing to consider; Honda engineers are pretty darned smart, and they didn't just pull the weight (and more importantly the weight distribution) out of a hat, they did the calculus and determined what would be the optimal configuration (which by definition is always a compromise) for a car which will see both stop and go driving as well as high RPM operations.
Yeah, it's pretty obvious you're talking out of your ***.
#7
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
Not all "lightweigh flywheels" are created equal; the weight and the distribution of said weight is key; don't be foolish enough to compare a BrandX "lightweight flywheel" and one from Honda designed by them for one of their cars.
Trending Topics
#8
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Sep 2011
Location: SC
Posts: 92
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
Theoretical physics aside, let's get back to the point. Why would I lose approx. 25% in mpg by installing an 11lb flywheel, stage 1.5 clutch, ss lines and ESMM inserts?
Would an alignment help? I can't think of any reason why these mods have lowered my fuel economy by so much.
Would an alignment help? I can't think of any reason why these mods have lowered my fuel economy by so much.
#12
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: La Puente!"626"
Posts: 3,478
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
i have an 03 ep3 (NO MODs) all stock. Ive done the oil changes normally,tranny fluid has been changed (honda MTF),Spark plug changed(NGK iridium),Alignment was done last saturday AND my gas milage is HORRIBLE. I had a half tank,drove my car roughly 60 miles and my car is on EMPTY. I drive like a normal human NO Speeding. My car has about 90k and i use Chevron 91. WHAT U THINKS THE PROBLEM?
#13
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
i have an 03 ep3 (NO MODs) all stock. Ive done the oil changes normally,tranny fluid has been changed (honda MTF),Spark plug changed(NGK iridium),Alignment was done last saturday AND my gas milage is HORRIBLE. I had a half tank,drove my car roughly 60 miles and my car is on EMPTY. I drive like a normal human NO Speeding. My car has about 90k and i use Chevron 91. WHAT U THINKS THE PROBLEM?
Regarding the Chevron 91; unless I miss my guess, you're using fuel with too high of an AKI rating; doesn't your Owner's Manual recommend 87 AKI fuel? If so, that could be a reason your fuel economy is lower than it should be.
#15
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: La Puente!"626"
Posts: 3,478
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
fuel tank and owners manual says use premium fuel only. No CEL,i also did valve adjustment not long ago. Im the Original Owner so i know all maintains has been done.
#16
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
Sorry, I missed my guess regarding the fuel quality (missed the RSX/EP3 reference in the forum name). Question, does 91 AKI fuel qualify as Premium fuel in your part of the country? I ask because here in New England, 91 AKI fuel isn't available; we get 87, 89, and 93. Is 91 considered Premium?
#18
Honda-Tech Member
#19
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
I don't know much about aligning a new clutch, but would a slightly misaligned clutch cause a mpg drop? Then again, if it is misaligned, you'd notice more issues, probably slipping & clutch odor right?
Assuming none of the recently installed parts could cause a 5-10mpg drop, I'd concentrate on the regular tune-up items: plugs/ignition/fuel delivery, valve job, etc.
Although it seems like the CEL & no cat existed prior to the parts install & MPG drop, getting rid of the emissions engine code would be first on my list.
Assuming none of the recently installed parts could cause a 5-10mpg drop, I'd concentrate on the regular tune-up items: plugs/ignition/fuel delivery, valve job, etc.
Although it seems like the CEL & no cat existed prior to the parts install & MPG drop, getting rid of the emissions engine code would be first on my list.
#21
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
No prob.
Another guess: I've read our in-tank fuel pumps just have a metal mesh/screen around them to filter, as opposed to an in-line fuel filter; so chances are the pump wouldn't be clogged... but would a failing or worn pump cause a drop in mpg?
Another guess: I've read our in-tank fuel pumps just have a metal mesh/screen around them to filter, as opposed to an in-line fuel filter; so chances are the pump wouldn't be clogged... but would a failing or worn pump cause a drop in mpg?
#22
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: SE-MI
Posts: 125
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
This will sound crazy, but it's free and can't hurt you, so give it a try: Reset the ECU and then perform an idle relearn.
1) Disconnect both battery cables.
2) Connect a jumper wire (if you have one with alligator clips, this will be easy) from the positive cable to the negative one. Make sure neither cable is touching the battery!
3) Leave it there for 10 minutes.
3.5) Reconnect the battery cables to their respective terminals.
4) Start the vehicle. Let it idle, do not touch the gas. Wait for the cooling fan to cycle on and off, twice.
5) Switch off the engine, then immediately restart it.
I'm going on the assumption that if, as another poster said, the lighter flywheel could have that sort of effect on the cylinders firing, then doing this could possibly correct that. Or, it could be that the shop that did the work disconnected the negative terminal before starting the clutch replacement; it's rare, but some technicians will actually follow every step outlined in a repair procedure, and disconnecting the ground is often step 1.
Outside of that, I can't imagine how a clutch/flywheel replacement could have any effect on your fuel economy, which is determined by the ECU and its supporting cast of sensors, the failure of any of which would result in DTC and warning light.
1) Disconnect both battery cables.
2) Connect a jumper wire (if you have one with alligator clips, this will be easy) from the positive cable to the negative one. Make sure neither cable is touching the battery!
3) Leave it there for 10 minutes.
3.5) Reconnect the battery cables to their respective terminals.
4) Start the vehicle. Let it idle, do not touch the gas. Wait for the cooling fan to cycle on and off, twice.
5) Switch off the engine, then immediately restart it.
I'm going on the assumption that if, as another poster said, the lighter flywheel could have that sort of effect on the cylinders firing, then doing this could possibly correct that. Or, it could be that the shop that did the work disconnected the negative terminal before starting the clutch replacement; it's rare, but some technicians will actually follow every step outlined in a repair procedure, and disconnecting the ground is often step 1.
Outside of that, I can't imagine how a clutch/flywheel replacement could have any effect on your fuel economy, which is determined by the ECU and its supporting cast of sensors, the failure of any of which would result in DTC and warning light.
Last edited by Sugar Shane; 10-08-2012 at 08:10 PM. Reason: Forgot one step.
#24
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
Anyway, I really doubt it's due to grease/oil (wish it's be the case then problem will be auto-resolved in a few hundred miles later). What I'm afraid is that the new flywheel as you mentioned is light than the original. Hmmm your engine must put more force (which result in more gas) to compensate your light poor flywheel that try harder to turn the transmission whereas before it didn't have to try hard since it was heavier and stronger.
#25
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: May 2009
Location: Netherlands
Posts: 38
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Plummeting gas mileage
What if there is friction that was't there before. Let's say the gearbox wasn't alligned
right after the clutch/flywheel work. Or a bearing that is turing tight?
Can this happen? Or is the gearbox / engine pairing foolproof.
Wild guesses, I'm trying to help.
right after the clutch/flywheel work. Or a bearing that is turing tight?
Can this happen? Or is the gearbox / engine pairing foolproof.
Wild guesses, I'm trying to help.