Fender Bender, the car would most likely get written off by insurance, so Im looking to do a self repair or pay the shop.
Would I be able to pop the fender back into place? Not too concerned about paint.

 

You can replace the fender, you ain't poppin **** out. Door ruined too.

 

car-part.com hunt around the wrecking yards near you. They made a bazillion Civic's, should be easy to find fenders and doors in the correct color. Probably $100 for a mint fender and $300 for the door.