Is my clutch shot?
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 0
From: Buffalo NY/Fort Bragg NC
Go to start my car after work, as the car is cranking it is also trying lurch forward. Reverse grinds trying to go in. The car goes thru the gears whil car is off just fine. Fluid levels are fine. Clutch has same firmness as I recall it ever having.
When I'm driving I can trucker-shift it w/out using the clutch.
There were ZERO warning signs of it failing. It drove to work fine, but didn't make it out of work fine.
Just as an FYI, it was flooding at work earlier and I drove thru water to the bottom of the bumper. I dont know if that would have done anything or not.
When I'm driving I can trucker-shift it w/out using the clutch.
There were ZERO warning signs of it failing. It drove to work fine, but didn't make it out of work fine.
Just as an FYI, it was flooding at work earlier and I drove thru water to the bottom of the bumper. I dont know if that would have done anything or not.
dont alot of honda grinds in reverse???
my friends has 3 diffrent honda and each one grind in reverse and so does my
and when u were shifting w/o clutch was it going straight into a diffrent gear or only neutral??
my friends has 3 diffrent honda and each one grind in reverse and so does my
and when u were shifting w/o clutch was it going straight into a diffrent gear or only neutral??
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 0
From: Buffalo NY/Fort Bragg NC
When I shift w/out the clutch, I can go thru all the gears. Its just a bitch if I have to stop since it wont go into first unless I'm stopped and I shut the car off.
theineffable
Trending Topics
need a new clutch mate! same thing happened to me getting off work to. found out my throwout bearing, clutch disc, n pressure plate was all messed up when i took out my tranny to look at it. but it could be something else though.
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 0
From: Buffalo NY/Fort Bragg NC
Wow thats just wonderful man. I cant believe this ****ing thing. The clutch never slipped or otherwise that would tell me the clutch is going bad though, which really REALLY pisses me off.
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 0
From: Buffalo NY/Fort Bragg NC
your missing what I'm saying. This transmission does NOT grind ANY gears. but since it's been broken, I cant put it in ANY gear and have to start the car in first gear and "trucker shift" it. I can TURN ON the car in reverse, but I cant shift to it since the clutch or something is ****ed up.
But yes the 1st-reverse trick worked on my HX
But yes the 1st-reverse trick worked on my HX
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 0
From: Buffalo NY/Fort Bragg NC
Well I had 2 honda heads look at the car today. I drove like 8 hours both ways to meet them. They said they are 75% sure its the slave cylinder. But it COULD be the throwout bearing.
So on my trip home, I pull up to a red light. Shut the car off, but it in first and wait. Light turns green, so I start the car and take of in 1st gear. There is a slight, odd, clunking noise coming from engine compartment somewhere. I continue on. I pull up to another red light a few miles later. Go thru the same procedures, only this time as I"m pulling away, there is another metallic clunking noise (sounded like the motor slightly shifting or something I dont know) and now my clutch works fine! I drove home a few hundred miles with it working!!
What. The. ****. Is going on?
So on my trip home, I pull up to a red light. Shut the car off, but it in first and wait. Light turns green, so I start the car and take of in 1st gear. There is a slight, odd, clunking noise coming from engine compartment somewhere. I continue on. I pull up to another red light a few miles later. Go thru the same procedures, only this time as I"m pulling away, there is another metallic clunking noise (sounded like the motor slightly shifting or something I dont know) and now my clutch works fine! I drove home a few hundred miles with it working!!
What. The. ****. Is going on?
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 0
From: Buffalo NY/Fort Bragg NC
Wow thanks for reminding me! Actually, what happened was driving thru the deep water (over the front lip almost half way up the bumper) had somehow caused the clutch or something to seize. After several HUNDRED miles of driving, upon pulling up to a red light, it out of nowhere started working again.
does anyone have any input as to how to fix this? i cant see what is wrong with mine, removed the tranny and the clutch/release bearing/flywheel are all fine.
i replaced the release bearing and rebuilt the gearbox 2000km's ago
problem happened 2 days after a bit of "spirited" driving
there were no signs until it suddenly started do the same thing as OP
HELP!!!!
edit: to clarify, the clutch pressure plate/disc was not replaced as it was only 20 000km's old at that stage
i replaced the release bearing and rebuilt the gearbox 2000km's ago
problem happened 2 days after a bit of "spirited" driving
there were no signs until it suddenly started do the same thing as OP
HELP!!!!

edit: to clarify, the clutch pressure plate/disc was not replaced as it was only 20 000km's old at that stage
Last edited by sw1fty; Sep 20, 2009 at 04:35 AM.
Wow thanks for reminding me! Actually, what happened was driving thru the deep water (over the front lip almost half way up the bumper) had somehow caused the clutch or something to seize. After several HUNDRED miles of driving, upon pulling up to a red light, it out of nowhere started working again.
bleeding the slave on my old protege5 was really easy.
Thread Starter
Honda-Tech Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 1,368
Likes: 0
From: Buffalo NY/Fort Bragg NC
Honestly I've never found it, but they claim there is a bolt near where the pedal attaches to the firewall. Thats about all I know man


