Turbo or K-Swap?
#1
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Texas
Posts: 519
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Turbo or K-Swap?
Hello all. I have a simple question that has been bugging me for a while. I'm about ready to start some major work on my motor, here's some info.
I have a 1993 four door EG, with a stock D-series(d15) with less than 100,000 miles. The question is, would it be more beneficial to purchase a turbo kit for the D-series and call it quits; or I can buy a complete K-Swap from a friend for a little bit more than the turbo kit.
Comments/Opinions?
I have a 1993 four door EG, with a stock D-series(d15) with less than 100,000 miles. The question is, would it be more beneficial to purchase a turbo kit for the D-series and call it quits; or I can buy a complete K-Swap from a friend for a little bit more than the turbo kit.
Comments/Opinions?
#2
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: SFV 818
Posts: 347
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
im in the same boat but i made my decision between a D16Z6 turbo or K20A2 swap. ill write down my opinions on the two
D Series Turbo
Pros
* Much Cheaper
* Easy to do
Cons
* Reliability is decreased (not saying its gonna suck, just decreased)
* Less power potential
* Requires more attention in terms of maintenance
K-Series Swap
Pros
* More reliable
* More potential
* Better gas mileage
Cons
* EXPENSIVE!!!
Although you may be able to pick up a K engine or tranny cheap the supporting mods add up quick. I decided to spend the extra money and get the k swap mainly due to reliability. N/A cars that go turbo soley dependent upon the tune. Though you may be at a "safe" level, you still are pushing much more tq through the transmission than Honda intended. I dont know how the d series trans holds up but a k series trans with any FI is gonna suck. Maybe im just paranoid because the k series transmissions are garbage since they suffer from 2nd & 3rd gear grind/pop out. ask away if you have any questions
*edit*
I forgot to mention that do realize that if you turbo the d15 in your car right now, youre turboing a 100,000 mile motor. get a compression check done if youre going that route
D Series Turbo
Pros
* Much Cheaper
* Easy to do
Cons
* Reliability is decreased (not saying its gonna suck, just decreased)
* Less power potential
* Requires more attention in terms of maintenance
K-Series Swap
Pros
* More reliable
* More potential
* Better gas mileage
Cons
* EXPENSIVE!!!
Although you may be able to pick up a K engine or tranny cheap the supporting mods add up quick. I decided to spend the extra money and get the k swap mainly due to reliability. N/A cars that go turbo soley dependent upon the tune. Though you may be at a "safe" level, you still are pushing much more tq through the transmission than Honda intended. I dont know how the d series trans holds up but a k series trans with any FI is gonna suck. Maybe im just paranoid because the k series transmissions are garbage since they suffer from 2nd & 3rd gear grind/pop out. ask away if you have any questions
*edit*
I forgot to mention that do realize that if you turbo the d15 in your car right now, youre turboing a 100,000 mile motor. get a compression check done if youre going that route
#3
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Jan 2009
Location: Orange Park, FL
Posts: 697
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
why would it be between a k-swap and a turbo d-series? Thats like complete opposites. Have you ever done a k-swap before? **** isnt easy or cheap by any means.
#5
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: SFV 818
Posts: 347
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
of course not but maybe he is in the same boat that i was in and trying to decide whether the extra money spent is worth the advantages to a k series and to me it is
#7
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA
Posts: 595
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
I would most definitely spend the extra money on a K-swap. Reliability is truely a big issue here and D-series motors now have like at least 100k miles on them. I mean mine already have like 210k but yea it's bone stock. If you are planning to turbo a D-series, I would suggest that you rebuild the motor before any forced induction.
You better be prepared to throw some money and time down if your going to go a K-swap.
You better be prepared to throw some money and time down if your going to go a K-swap.
Trending Topics
#9
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
I did some research on this also. You can find a d16z6 for very cheap. Throw in some vitara pistons and the FJ custom length rods and your good for over 450whp easy. Here is the link http://fjdistributors.com/product_in...roducts_id=564 That is for the entire rebuild kit for the bottom end, only $600. Than boost all you want. Much more cheaper and built at that than a stock bolt on Kseries.
You try to make over 300whp with a K series without boost.
You try to make over 300whp with a K series without boost.
#11
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
Didnt say it wasn't possible, But now you tell me how much it would cost to build the K to make that much power all motor, on top of the K swap price already. How would drivability be with an all motor K series with over 300whp ?
#13
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: San Francisco, CA, USA
Posts: 595
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
I did some research on this also. You can find a d16z6 for very cheap. Throw in some vitara pistons and the FJ custom length rods and your good for over 450whp easy. Here is the link http://fjdistributors.com/product_in...roducts_id=564 That is for the entire rebuild kit for the bottom end, only $600. Than boost all you want. Much more cheaper and built at that than a stock bolt on Kseries.
You try to make over 300whp with a K series without boost.
You try to make over 300whp with a K series without boost.
#14
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Texas
Posts: 519
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
Well here's how much I plan on spending for the K swap. I have a buddy who had his RSX-S rear ended, and he said that he will sell me everything for 1500. What he told me is that the only extra things that I need to buy are the motor mounts. Can anyone help me to see what else I'll need?
#17
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
Do what I will be doing.
I have a K24 from a 06 CR-V that a friend wrecked and I bought the whole car from him for the motor 3 yrs ago.
I just bought a 06 SI tranny and RSX-S Shifter + mounts + Linkage.
Your going to have to get All that, motor, tranny, ecu's, RSX Shifter + Mounts + Linkage.
Then Mounts, I reccomend Hasport.
Custom exhaust made, your looking at about 400-500 for a better header ( Skunk2, or DC) and then the rest of the exhaust.
The Oil feed lines, custom coolant/radiator hoses and lines, Speedo Cluster lines if you want that to work, tach, etc.
All in all, a well done swap should run around an extra 2.5k if you have what I stated earlier.
So in total, without anything, this is like a 6-7k swap.
Now, a cheapo swap can be done, but there goes your reliability for the swap/it holding right. But you could cheap out with EBay brand mounts, exhaust, lines etc etc for like an extra 1k...But that'll fall apart eventually.
Do it the right way from the start.
Im waiting to find a clean EK hatch/Teggy so i can begin my build and post it up here.
Whatever you choose though, goodluck. Its your car!
I have a K24 from a 06 CR-V that a friend wrecked and I bought the whole car from him for the motor 3 yrs ago.
I just bought a 06 SI tranny and RSX-S Shifter + mounts + Linkage.
Your going to have to get All that, motor, tranny, ecu's, RSX Shifter + Mounts + Linkage.
Then Mounts, I reccomend Hasport.
Custom exhaust made, your looking at about 400-500 for a better header ( Skunk2, or DC) and then the rest of the exhaust.
The Oil feed lines, custom coolant/radiator hoses and lines, Speedo Cluster lines if you want that to work, tach, etc.
All in all, a well done swap should run around an extra 2.5k if you have what I stated earlier.
So in total, without anything, this is like a 6-7k swap.
Now, a cheapo swap can be done, but there goes your reliability for the swap/it holding right. But you could cheap out with EBay brand mounts, exhaust, lines etc etc for like an extra 1k...But that'll fall apart eventually.
Do it the right way from the start.
Im waiting to find a clean EK hatch/Teggy so i can begin my build and post it up here.
Whatever you choose though, goodluck. Its your car!
#18
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
Also, I forgot to add, keep in mind you have to set up a fuel system.
New Rails, Fuel pump, lines, etc.
Some gauges for monitoring everything will be useful to.
Mini radiator, Fans.
Goodluck!
New Rails, Fuel pump, lines, etc.
Some gauges for monitoring everything will be useful to.
Mini radiator, Fans.
Goodluck!
#19
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Texas
Posts: 519
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
As for the comment about me being all talk and I won't do anything...We'll see.
And back to the topic, as stated before I will be getting everything - motor, tranny, axles, ECU, linkage etc.. A complete swap for 1500 minus the mounts. Plus he will install it for me so I can get an idea on how it works..
I thank you for your comments 'streetracerkam', but you priced the swap a little different from what I'm dealing with.
Once I get everything that comes in the car itself (minus the mounts) I need to know what else I'm dealing with. (the exhaust comment was good, didn't think of that.)
And back to the topic, as stated before I will be getting everything - motor, tranny, axles, ECU, linkage etc.. A complete swap for 1500 minus the mounts. Plus he will install it for me so I can get an idea on how it works..
I thank you for your comments 'streetracerkam', but you priced the swap a little different from what I'm dealing with.
Once I get everything that comes in the car itself (minus the mounts) I need to know what else I'm dealing with. (the exhaust comment was good, didn't think of that.)
#20
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
Well here's how much I plan on spending for the K swap. I have a buddy who had his RSX-S rear ended, and he said that he will sell me everything for 1500. What he told me is that the only extra things that I need to buy are the motor mounts. Can anyone help me to see what else I'll need?
you better do some research buddy...
And some of yall are making stuff up... A single cam with 100k will run forever with a well maintained boost setup...
Im in the same boat except I have a GSR and want to be boosted bad... But the reliability of the K and performance out the box is still hard to pass up... Up to now I still havent made up my mind...
#21
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: The Beach, De, USA
Posts: 1,068
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
Op, if you can get all the parts from your buddies RSX for 1500 pick it up and sit on it for a while. While your thinking and buying the rest of the required parts for the build just keep in mind you can sell the parts for WAY more. Just th K swap itself sells for a hell of alot more than that. Not to mention, you can strip the interior of his car and have some sweet *** seats in your car as well. It all depends really on what YOU want to do with all this. I would definately go for the K, and if not buy it anyway just to strip it down and sell the parts and let that pay for your turbo build.
#22
Re: Turbo or K-Swap?
Fuel Rail, you cannot retain the one of the RSX because it mounts differently from throughout the car ( correct me if Im wrong, but thats what I assume cosnidering thats what I need for my K24 swap from a CR-V).
All the lines for the fuel rail..
Your going to need a walbro..your stock pump in the tank wont push it for the K.
A tune will be needed, badly, after you do all this.
The various connectors/linkages... and attachments for like the Speedo to work and whatnot, its going to be expensive.
Even if you get everything from that rsx, your still looking at atleast 2k extra for everything to be right, or a slacky **** job for 1k...Hasport mounts are 600 themselves. Your gonna need a passenger side CR-V mount to (50-150), Speedo Lines and attachment for it to work and tach (100-300) aftermarket fuel rail ( 200-400) Full exhaust, with header ( 800) mounts ( hassport are 600, innonative 450), oil cooler etc. It's going to be a lot of money and nerves, but more power to you if you get it done.
I know I am, i just need to find a nice hatch to drop all my stuff in.
All the lines for the fuel rail..
Your going to need a walbro..your stock pump in the tank wont push it for the K.
A tune will be needed, badly, after you do all this.
The various connectors/linkages... and attachments for like the Speedo to work and whatnot, its going to be expensive.
Even if you get everything from that rsx, your still looking at atleast 2k extra for everything to be right, or a slacky **** job for 1k...Hasport mounts are 600 themselves. Your gonna need a passenger side CR-V mount to (50-150), Speedo Lines and attachment for it to work and tach (100-300) aftermarket fuel rail ( 200-400) Full exhaust, with header ( 800) mounts ( hassport are 600, innonative 450), oil cooler etc. It's going to be a lot of money and nerves, but more power to you if you get it done.
I know I am, i just need to find a nice hatch to drop all my stuff in.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post