large turbo on small displacement... why?
#1
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
large turbo on small displacement... why?
I just dont get some people when they build their 1.6 or 1.8 they put a big turbo that doesnt spool till 5500 and with shitty gearing it takes them forever to get there. Why? Its just dumb to have the turbo spool so high IMO with long gearing and a final gear that puts you out of boost when you shift lol. I've seen so many Honda owners do this I really dont get it.
#4
RESIDENT
iTrader: (6)
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
It all depends on the setup, a friend of mine is running a gt35r on a 2Ltr gsr, yes it does spool a little slow, full boost around 5200rpm, but from there to 9500rpm that thing rips and does not fall out of boost when shifting. I do agree that there is overkill on some turbos, but if the builder/tuner knows a little something about turbo setups you can actually run a decent sized snail.
#5
Man U FTW
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
Yes, some people are stupid. I'll give you that. To address your actual concern however, those of us with Honda B series engines, dont have the option of large displacement. In order to build a setup that makes 400whp or so, we have to run a large turbo but that doesn't mean it has to be slow spooling or slow in general. Even though our engines are small, they are remarkably efficient which allows us to run larger turbos with better success than a comparable Evo, WRX, DSMpoop, etc.
Even my own turbo setup by your definition is laggy and dumb, but i can tell you that although the graph shows full boost seems to be about 5k, it starts coming on much earlier and with a bit of brake-boosting, i can have full boost at a hair over 3k rpm.
The biggest thing to remember is to match your turbo to your setup and goals rather than just going by what everyone else says or by what is popular at the time. I was just posting in a thread where the OP wanted 315-365whp and the first suggestion was a GT35R...really?!? Thats where people start acting in accordance with your original claims.
Here's my graph for comparison...not my final graph (which is lost) but one of the random pulls along the way
Even my own turbo setup by your definition is laggy and dumb, but i can tell you that although the graph shows full boost seems to be about 5k, it starts coming on much earlier and with a bit of brake-boosting, i can have full boost at a hair over 3k rpm.
The biggest thing to remember is to match your turbo to your setup and goals rather than just going by what everyone else says or by what is popular at the time. I was just posting in a thread where the OP wanted 315-365whp and the first suggestion was a GT35R...really?!? Thats where people start acting in accordance with your original claims.
Here's my graph for comparison...not my final graph (which is lost) but one of the random pulls along the way
#6
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
Yes, some people are stupid. I'll give you that. To address your actual concern however, those of us with Honda B series engines, dont have the option of large displacement. In order to build a setup that makes 400whp or so, we have to run a large turbo but that doesn't mean it has to be slow spooling or slow in general.
#7
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Apr 2005
Location: Wichita, KS
Posts: 407
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
what 57 trim doesnt "spool" untill 5500???????
I had a t3/t4 57trim on my stock ls before i built it and threw a vtec head on it. It hit 8psi around 4500rpm.
Also, the guys using larger turbos ARE doing so because they drag race. Your not going to put a 35R on a circut car.
I do agree that there are those people who just want a "DD" with a large dyno number. There are those that just get too large of a turbo to meet their goals i.e Schister66's example. They are usually misguided and/or uninformed.
I had a t3/t4 57trim on my stock ls before i built it and threw a vtec head on it. It hit 8psi around 4500rpm.
Also, the guys using larger turbos ARE doing so because they drag race. Your not going to put a 35R on a circut car.
I do agree that there are those people who just want a "DD" with a large dyno number. There are those that just get too large of a turbo to meet their goals i.e Schister66's example. They are usually misguided and/or uninformed.
Trending Topics
#8
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: B-MORE CAREFUL!!, MD, 21229
Posts: 502
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
Alls I know is my 57 trim hit full boost by 3-35k on my bone stock ls motor, it was bad ***!
Other than that, there is NO way to answer this. EVERYONE is diff., and do **** for diff. reasons. I run a 2.0l gsr with a gt40, yea it doesn't hit boost till about 52ish. Think about it though, when drag racing @ what point does your car go under maybe 6500? Not sure about you guys, but I'm on the gas and shiftin my *** off, and I don't drop out of boost. That is the point for the big turbos, TOP END, with out them you would't be seeing the #'s that everyone is doing. For a DD or circuit track, yea it's just dumb, but some people have to have the best of the best. I mean I don't own a trailer so I drive my car to the track and back, and enjoys night and weekend cruisin with it, and honestly I would rather have a laggy turbo on the street. Why would you want to be spinning and boosting that low in the r's? Mine drives like a normal all motor car, unless you wake her up and hit the gas....
Bottom line is, everyone is diff., and everyone has diff. goals. I think now a days though you see more and more of kids using daddy's money or what not, and they buy what the big boys run, just to be cool.
Other than that, there is NO way to answer this. EVERYONE is diff., and do **** for diff. reasons. I run a 2.0l gsr with a gt40, yea it doesn't hit boost till about 52ish. Think about it though, when drag racing @ what point does your car go under maybe 6500? Not sure about you guys, but I'm on the gas and shiftin my *** off, and I don't drop out of boost. That is the point for the big turbos, TOP END, with out them you would't be seeing the #'s that everyone is doing. For a DD or circuit track, yea it's just dumb, but some people have to have the best of the best. I mean I don't own a trailer so I drive my car to the track and back, and enjoys night and weekend cruisin with it, and honestly I would rather have a laggy turbo on the street. Why would you want to be spinning and boosting that low in the r's? Mine drives like a normal all motor car, unless you wake her up and hit the gas....
Bottom line is, everyone is diff., and everyone has diff. goals. I think now a days though you see more and more of kids using daddy's money or what not, and they buy what the big boys run, just to be cool.
#9
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (3)
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
Alls I know is my 57 trim hit full boost by 3-35k on my bone stock ls motor, it was bad ***!
Other than that, there is NO way to answer this. EVERYONE is diff., and do **** for diff. reasons. I run a 2.0l gsr with a gt40, yea it doesn't hit boost till about 52ish. Think about it though, when drag racing @ what point does your car go under maybe 6500? Not sure about you guys, but I'm on the gas and shiftin my *** off, and I don't drop out of boost. That is the point for the big turbos, TOP END, with out them you would't be seeing the #'s that everyone is doing. For a DD or circuit track, yea it's just dumb, but some people have to have the best of the best. I mean I don't own a trailer so I drive my car to the track and back, and enjoys night and weekend cruisin with it, and honestly I would rather have a laggy turbo on the street. Why would you want to be spinning and boosting that low in the r's? Mine drives like a normal all motor car, unless you wake her up and hit the gas....
Bottom line is, everyone is diff., and everyone has diff. goals. I think now a days though you see more and more of kids using daddy's money or what not, and they buy what the big boys run, just to be cool.
Other than that, there is NO way to answer this. EVERYONE is diff., and do **** for diff. reasons. I run a 2.0l gsr with a gt40, yea it doesn't hit boost till about 52ish. Think about it though, when drag racing @ what point does your car go under maybe 6500? Not sure about you guys, but I'm on the gas and shiftin my *** off, and I don't drop out of boost. That is the point for the big turbos, TOP END, with out them you would't be seeing the #'s that everyone is doing. For a DD or circuit track, yea it's just dumb, but some people have to have the best of the best. I mean I don't own a trailer so I drive my car to the track and back, and enjoys night and weekend cruisin with it, and honestly I would rather have a laggy turbo on the street. Why would you want to be spinning and boosting that low in the r's? Mine drives like a normal all motor car, unless you wake her up and hit the gas....
Bottom line is, everyone is diff., and everyone has diff. goals. I think now a days though you see more and more of kids using daddy's money or what not, and they buy what the big boys run, just to be cool.
#13
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
my b18c-r (fully forged) running 57trim hits 1.2bar around 4.8k rpm on a street car i find this just right. not too laggy and power doesnt drop off between gear change. i see alot of people run massive turbo's on street cars and all they do is light the tyres up whenever they hit boost, big turbo's can be good as long as the car has the right setup ie not just thrown a gt40 something on a stock ls
#14
Honda-Tech Member
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2008
Location: Clifton, nj
Posts: 217
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
i run a big turbo bc its for drag race apps i come out the line at 7800rpm i rev til 10,200 and my motor doesnt go lower then 7500 on any gear... if i show one of my data logs youll see boost in evry gear...
if its for the streets stick w/ something that makes you feel the spool @ 3000 rpm like a GT30R or so....
if its for the streets stick w/ something that makes you feel the spool @ 3000 rpm like a GT30R or so....
#17
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
i run a big turbo bc its for drag race apps i come out the line at 7800rpm i rev til 10,200 and my motor doesnt go lower then 7500 on any gear... if i show one of my data logs youll see boost in evry gear...
if its for the streets stick w/ something that makes you feel the spool @ 3000 rpm like a GT30R or so....
if its for the streets stick w/ something that makes you feel the spool @ 3000 rpm like a GT30R or so....
agree
#18
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
RPM is the reason. 1.8 liters at 8000 rpm is like 3.6L at 4000 rpm. A stock b16 with a medium sized turbo is making noticable power over stock by 4000rpm. You have another 4-4.5k rpm of good power after that. Hugely oversized turbos are silly, yeah, but a ~60lb/min turbo can be really fun on a small engine as long as you have good gearing, which GSRs and B16s come with.
If you fall out of boost with the typical honda setup between shifts then you are shifting about 3000 rpm too early.
Personally I can't stand a small engine with a small turbo on a fwd car. Traction is important and without some road speed you just cant hook up a t28 on high boost without slicks. On rwd small turbos on small engines is a blast though
If you fall out of boost with the typical honda setup between shifts then you are shifting about 3000 rpm too early.
Personally I can't stand a small engine with a small turbo on a fwd car. Traction is important and without some road speed you just cant hook up a t28 on high boost without slicks. On rwd small turbos on small engines is a blast though
#19
Honda-Tech Member
Re: large turbo on small displacement... why?
Im rolling a GT28r (the turbo that comes with the Dseries edelbrock kit) on my LS and its the best DD turbo ever. Its instantaneous full boost at any rpm above 4500 and will make the wastegate (10psi) @ 3400rpm from a slow start.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post