Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
#1
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
So hey guys, not sure if this is the right place to ask but I'm looking for some advice in terms of stick shift.
I don't know how to drive stick (yeah I know, horrible) anyways I really want to. I almost bought this 97 civic that was stick...
Anyways, I wanna buy an Integra and I'll eventually modify it. My friend was telling me I could always change it to stick in the future should I buy anew auto, which are the more abundant in terms of availabilityin sales. Sounds like a good idea, get an auto, learn stick then change... but is it more beneficial to just learn stick before buying it? how do these options compare to each other?
this noob needs help 😂
I don't know how to drive stick (yeah I know, horrible) anyways I really want to. I almost bought this 97 civic that was stick...
Anyways, I wanna buy an Integra and I'll eventually modify it. My friend was telling me I could always change it to stick in the future should I buy anew auto, which are the more abundant in terms of availabilityin sales. Sounds like a good idea, get an auto, learn stick then change... but is it more beneficial to just learn stick before buying it? how do these options compare to each other?
this noob needs help 😂
#2
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
You would think someone would tell me why my post got closed and moved to the integra section of the forum.
I had some decent responsesized for those guys too.
One dude got the troll part right though, even if it wasn't my first intention of making this post. and of course there are no manual cars in the wild...
thanks to those with the civil responses though 👌
I had some decent responsesized for those guys too.
One dude got the troll part right though, even if it wasn't my first intention of making this post. and of course there are no manual cars in the wild...
thanks to those with the civil responses though 👌
#3
Moderator
iTrader: (14)
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
Your friend is making an idiot of himself. Changing a full transmission and pedal set from auto to manual is a huge endeavour and major pain in the ***.
Buy a stock and learn in the parking lot like the rest of us. There's no short cuts to learning it by "easing into it".
As Yoda says ... "do, or do not. There is no try ."
Buy a stock and learn in the parking lot like the rest of us. There's no short cuts to learning it by "easing into it".
As Yoda says ... "do, or do not. There is no try ."
#4
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
I looked up the process and I agree, seems like a huge pain.
the reason I was asking was because the answer to this question would help me decide on when to get myself anot her car. I'm getting a stock stick when I save enough money again.
I was just looking at the difficulties experienced with this option.
the reason I was asking was because the answer to this question would help me decide on when to get myself anot her car. I'm getting a stock stick when I save enough money again.
I was just looking at the difficulties experienced with this option.
#5
Fish Twig
Join Date: Nov 2005
Location: Still hunting that foo up there
Posts: 15,555
Received 309 Likes
on
285 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
You would think someone would tell me why my post got closed and moved to the integra section of the forum.
I had some decent responsesized for those guys too.
One dude got the troll part right though, even if it wasn't my first intention of making this post. and of course there are no manual cars in the wild...
thanks to those with the civil responses though 👌
I had some decent responsesized for those guys too.
One dude got the troll part right though, even if it wasn't my first intention of making this post. and of course there are no manual cars in the wild...
thanks to those with the civil responses though 👌
#6
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#7
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
Just buy the standard Integra. You'll have some growing pains, you'll stall out a few times, and you'll grind a few gears, but at the end of it you will be WAY happier with the manual Integra than you would be with an auto. You'd be bored with the auto after a few weeks, and it would take a lot of the excitement out of the overall build/car.
Also, the cost of doing an auto-manual swap and all the added work makes it even more of a good idea to just get the car you actually want the first time. Save up, and buy a clean manual teggy.
Edit: Some advice for actually learning stick - Go to a big/empty parking lot,and just practice rolling off into 1st gear over and over again. That's the hardest part of learning standard, is just dead starts (especially when you're on a hill and can't roll into the car behind you). It's really not that hard/bad, just spend a few hours practicing and after a couple weeks of daily driving the car it'll already be second nature.
Also, the cost of doing an auto-manual swap and all the added work makes it even more of a good idea to just get the car you actually want the first time. Save up, and buy a clean manual teggy.
Edit: Some advice for actually learning stick - Go to a big/empty parking lot,and just practice rolling off into 1st gear over and over again. That's the hardest part of learning standard, is just dead starts (especially when you're on a hill and can't roll into the car behind you). It's really not that hard/bad, just spend a few hours practicing and after a couple weeks of daily driving the car it'll already be second nature.
Trending Topics
#8
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
Just buy the standard Integra. You'll have some growing pains, you'll stall out a few times, and you'll grind a few gears, but at the end of it you will be WAY happier with the manual Integra than you would be with an auto. You'd be bored with the auto after a few weeks, and it would take a lot of the excitement out of the overall build/car.
Also, the cost of doing an auto-manual swap and all the added work makes it even more of a good idea to just get the car you actually want the first time. Save up, and buy a clean manual teggy.
Edit: Some advice for actually learning stick - Go to a big/empty parking lot,and just practice rolling off into 1st gear over and over again. That's the hardest part of learning standard, is just dead starts (especially when you're on a hill and can't roll into the car behind you). It's really not that hard/bad, just spend a few hours practicing and after a couple weeks of daily driving the car it'll already be second nature.
Also, the cost of doing an auto-manual swap and all the added work makes it even more of a good idea to just get the car you actually want the first time. Save up, and buy a clean manual teggy.
Edit: Some advice for actually learning stick - Go to a big/empty parking lot,and just practice rolling off into 1st gear over and over again. That's the hardest part of learning standard, is just dead starts (especially when you're on a hill and can't roll into the car behind you). It's really not that hard/bad, just spend a few hours practicing and after a couple weeks of daily driving the car it'll already be second nature.
#9
Moderator
iTrader: (14)
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
You can try, but it doesn't work that way. You don't master it getting into it once in a while as you drive the automatic. You'll actually make your learning curve even flatter going to work everyday in it. Take that 1st weekend you have the car and start learning. Like I said. There's no "easy way" getting into it with two cars and all that jazz.
If anything, with two cars it takes a much longer time period to learn.
If anything, with two cars it takes a much longer time period to learn.
#10
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
I understood what you said, I live 10 minutes from my job but always seem to be running late. I didn't want to be running late with a stick and keep stalling on the numerous lights on the way there. Being that my semester ends soon, I'll have time to spend most of the day practicing. Plus I drive out of state occasionally and didn't want one of those moments to come when I just started learning, I might never get there xD
But I will definitely get a stick soon (a car that comes that way) just saving up so I don't have to sell my car in order to buy it. I do get your points though.
But I will definitely get a stick soon (a car that comes that way) just saving up so I don't have to sell my car in order to buy it. I do get your points though.
#11
Honda-Tech Member
Join Date: Jan 2015
Location: SoCal
Posts: 126
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
If you bought a stick on a friday night and drove over the weekend, you would be fine going into work on monday. It's not that difficult to learn, and once you have a basic grasp of it, you may only stall a couple times a week.
Stop worrying and get one!
Stop worrying and get one!
#12
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
As I said, now I just have to save my money.
#14
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
LOL funny... I watched this exact video about a week or so ago. I do watch tutorials but have no actual car to practice in, yet...
#15
-Intl Steve Krew
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
It's seriously not hard to learn how to drive manual.
Clutch in, First gear, roll onto the throttle to 1500rpm, roll off the clutch, off you go.
I literally did not stall at all my first time learning how to drive manual, around the neighborhood, at night with no other cars on the road.
The first time I stalled was driving by myself and it was in the middle of traffic at a light. You learn real quick how not to stall out.
Clutch in, First gear, roll onto the throttle to 1500rpm, roll off the clutch, off you go.
I literally did not stall at all my first time learning how to drive manual, around the neighborhood, at night with no other cars on the road.
The first time I stalled was driving by myself and it was in the middle of traffic at a light. You learn real quick how not to stall out.
#16
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
It's seriously not hard to learn how to drive manual.
Clutch in, First gear, roll onto the throttle to 1500rpm, roll off the clutch, off you go.
I literally did not stall at all my first time learning how to drive manual, around the neighborhood, at night with no other cars on the road.
The first time I stalled was driving by myself and it was in the middle of traffic at a light. You learn real quick how not to stall out.
Clutch in, First gear, roll onto the throttle to 1500rpm, roll off the clutch, off you go.
I literally did not stall at all my first time learning how to drive manual, around the neighborhood, at night with no other cars on the road.
The first time I stalled was driving by myself and it was in the middle of traffic at a light. You learn real quick how not to stall out.
#19
Honda-Tech Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2016
Posts: 106
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
Rolling down a hill is probably the biggest fear I have. Luckily (or maybe not so lucky) is that my route from work-school-home has no significant hills.
#20
Moderator
iTrader: (14)
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
You can't guess anymore about "what if" situations. You have to DO.. Your brain and your body will help you dictate what to do as you're in the situation. But you have to DO IT. Can't just think of reasons NOT to do it, or you'll just get frustrated and walk away.
#21
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
Umm. that's what the brakes are for. you can be in neutral and use the brakes down-hill or (when you finally start understanding by doing) match the gear to the driveline as you go downhill.
You can't guess anymore about "what if" situations. You have to DO.. Your brain and your body will help you dictate what to do as you're in the situation. But you have to DO IT. Can't just think of reasons NOT to do it, or you'll just get frustrated and walk away.
You can't guess anymore about "what if" situations. You have to DO.. Your brain and your body will help you dictate what to do as you're in the situation. But you have to DO IT. Can't just think of reasons NOT to do it, or you'll just get frustrated and walk away.
Handbrake start/stops with the clutch rolling off are really easy once you get used to it.
#22
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
You guys had it easy, my dad took me into the hills in a Subaru station wagon and made me stop and start on the steep hills, no ebrake allowed. Next day, I was driving us to work across the GG bridge all the way down to Stanford. It literally takes less than a day to learn stick. Just get the stick.
#23
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
Yeah man, I practiced driving my car the night I got it, stalled once in the parking lot, and then drove it to school the next day no problem. There was a few pretty steep inclines too, though I probably only started from a stop on one of them. These cars are really easy to learn manual on.
#24
Moderator
iTrader: (14)
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
You guys had it easy, my dad took me into the hills in a Subaru station wagon and made me stop and start on the steep hills, no ebrake allowed. Next day, I was driving us to work across the GG bridge all the way down to Stanford. It literally takes less than a day to learn stick. Just get the stick.
#25
Honda-Tech Member
Re: Natural vs Man Made Stick Shift
That's how most of us did this., You considered that "abusive" learning? *snicker* My mom is the one that taught my brother how to drive a stick. My father taught me in about a day.. same method. "You wanna get around, get in there and do it!!" No manual, no book, just trial-by-fire.
He wanted me to understand and know what it feels like to lose control or have sudden events occur in a car, and correct them/recover. Definitely a good idea I think, because now when I'm dicking around in a car that has 1/2 that weight and way more responsive brakes/suspension, I'm very acutely aware of where the limits and lines are of the vehicle.